Publication Date:
2014-08-22
Description:
Electron-microprobe analysis, single-crystal X-ray diffraction with an area detector, and high-resolution transmission electron microscopy show that minerals related to wagnerite, triplite and triploidite, which are monoclinic Mg, Fe and Mn phosphates with the formula Me 2+ 2 PO 4 (F,OH), constitute a modulated series based on the average triplite structure. Modulation occurs along b and may be commensurate with (2 b periodicity) or incommensurate but generally close to integer values (~3 b , ~5 b , ~7 b , ~9 b ), i.e. close to polytypic behaviour. As a result, the Mg- and F-dominant minerals magniotriplite and wagnerite can no longer be considered polymorphs of Mg 2 PO 4 F, i.e. , there is no basis for recognizing them as distinct species. Given that wagnerite has priority (1821 vs. 1951), the name magniotriplite should be discarded in favour of wagnerite. Hydroxylwagnerite, end-member Mg 2 PO 4 OH, occurs in pyrope megablasts along with talc, clinochlore, kyanite, rutile and secondary apatite in two samples from lenses of pyrope–kyanite–phengite–quartz-schist within metagranite in the coesite-bearing ultrahigh-pressure metamorphic unit of the Dora-Maira Massif, western Alps, Vallone di Gilba, Val Varaita, Piemonte, Italy. Electron microprobe analyses of holotype hydroxylwagnerite and of the crystal with the lowest F content gave in wt%: P 2 O 5 44.14, 43.99; SiO 2 0.28, 0.02; SO 3 –, 0.01; TiO 2 0.20, 0.16; Al 2 O 3 0.06, 0.03; MgO 48.82, 49.12; FeO 0.33, 0.48; MnO 0.01, 0.02; CaO 0.12, 0.10; Na 2 O 0.01, –; F 5.58, 4.67; H 2 O (calc) 2.94, 3.36; –O = F 2.35, 1.97; Sum 100.14, 99.98, corresponding to (Mg 1.954 Fe 0.007 Ca 0.003 Ti 0.004 Al 0.002 Na 0.001 ) =1.971 (P 1.003 Si 0.008 ) =1.011 O 4 (OH 0.526 F 0.474 ) =1 and (Mg 1.971 Fe 0.011 Ca 0.003 Ti 0.003 Al 0.001 ) =1.989 (P 1.002 Si 0.001 ) =1.003 O 4 (OH 0.603 F 0.397 ) =1 , respectively. Due to the paucity of material, H 2 O could not be measured, so OH was calculated from the deficit in F assuming stoichiometry, i.e. , by assuming F + OH = 1 per formula unit. Holotype hydroxylwagnerite is optically biaxial (+), α 1.584(1), β 1.586(1), 1.587(1) (589 nm); 2V Z (meas.) = 43(2)°; orientation Y = b . Single-crystal X-ray diffraction gives monoclinic symmetry, space group P 2 1 / c, a = 9.646(3) Å, b = 12.7314(16) Å, c = 11.980(4) Å, β = 108.38(4)°, V = 1396.2(8) Å 3 , Z = 16, i.e. , hydroxylwagnerite is the OH-dominant analogue of wagnerite [β-Mg 2 PO 4 (OH)] and a high-pressure polymorph of althausite, holtedahlite, and α- and -Mg 2 PO 4 (OH). We suggest that the group of minerals related to wagnerite, triplite and triploidite constitutes a triplite–triploidite supergroup that can be divided into F-dominant phosphates (triplite group), OH-dominant phosphates (triploidite group), O-dominant phosphates (staněkite group) and an OH-dominant arsenate (sarkinite). The distinction among the three groups and a potential fourth group is based only on chemical features, i.e. , occupancy of anion or cation sites. The structures of these minerals are all based on the average triplite structure, with a modulation controlled by the ratio of Mg, Fe 2+ , Fe 3+ and Mn 2+ ionic radii to (O,OH,F) ionic radii.
Print ISSN:
0935-1221
Electronic ISSN:
1617-4011
Topics:
Geosciences
Permalink