ALBERT

Description: Soil respiration compartments on an aging managed heathland: can model selection procedures contribute to our understanding of ecosystem processes? Biogeosciences Discussions, 9, 16239-16301, 2012 Author(s): G. R. Kopittke, E. E. van Loon, A. Tietema, and D. Asscheman Soil respiration studies are increasingly undertaken with the aim of quantifying C fluxes and predicting changes for the future. The interpretation of field data into annual C loss predictions requires the use of modeling tools which generally include model variables related to the underlying drivers of soil respiration, such as soil temperature, soil moisture and plant activity. Very few studies have reported using model selection procedures in which structurally different models are calibrated, then validated on separate observation datasets and the outcomes critically compared. This study utilized thorough model selection procedures to determine soil heterotrophic (microbial) and autotrophic (root) respiration for a heathland chronosequence. The model validation process identified that none of the six measured plant variables explained any data variation when included in models with soil temperature, which contradicts many current studies. The best predictive model used a generalized linear mixed effect model format with soil temperature as the only variable. There were no heterotrophic respiration differences between the community ages. In contrast, autotrophic respiration was significantly greater on the youngest vegetation (55 % of total soil respiration in summer) and decreased as the plants aged (oldest vegetation: 37 % of total soil respiration in summer). Total annual soil C loss from the youngest and oldest communities was estimated to be 650 and 435 g C m −2 yr −1 respectively. Heathlands are cultural landscapes which are managed through cyclical cutting, burning or grazing practices. Understanding the C fluxes from these ecosystems provides information on the optimal management cycle-time to maximize C uptake and minimize C output. Inclusion of the predicted soil fluxes into a preliminary ecosystem C balance suggested that the youngest vegetation is a C sink while the oldest vegetation is a C source, indicating that shorter management cycles could reduce C emissions.