ALBERT

Notes: A panel of untrained judges was asked to assess spreadability of selected solid edible fat samples (butter, margarine, low fat products) of different temperature with regard to hedonic preferences. Instrumental measurements were performed by cone penetration with constant load. The statistical analysis of the ranked sensory data showed significant spreadability optima in the apparent yield value range of approximately 30–60 kPa. Differences between the selected fats were not observed.

Notes: Subjects rated the intensities of 42 different attributes for 26 different bread products. Principal component analysis was used to categorize the breads based on their attribute ratings. The first two principal components were interpreted as a richness dimension and a nutrition/fiber dimension. The influence of these dimensions on sensory-specific satiety in bread products was investigated.Subjects tasted and rated their liking of small portions of a set of bread products representative of the extremes of the richness dimension and the nutrition/fiber dimension before and after eating a 400 calorie serving of one of the breads. Measurements of hunger were taken before and after the meal.Bread appeared resistant to sensory-specific satiety. The richness of the breads did not affect the amount of sensory-specific satiety. The high nutrition/fiber breads decreased hunger and tended to decrease liking more than the low nutrition/fiber breads.

Notes: Aroma concentrates from Alphonso and Totapuri mango pulps were prepared and the aroma stripped pulps were concentrated two folds. Ready to serve beverages were prepared from fresh mango pulps and pulp concentrates by adding different levels of aroma concentrates. Sensory evaluation of beverages showed that in the case of Alphonso mango addition of 50%, 75% and 100% aroma concentrate gave comparable quality while with Totapuri only 50% level showed comparable quality.The aroma stripped pulp concentrates were canned as such and after mixing with 50% aroma concentrates and stored at 25 × 5°C. Aroma concentrates were bottled and stored at 2°C. At different intervals of storage, beverages were prepared and evaluated. The results showed that throughout the storage period, beverages prepared from mango concentrates to which 50% aroma was added before canning was superior to those prepared from aroma stripped canned pulp concentrates to which aroma was added at the time of preparation of beverage indicating the effect of mango pulp on aroma stability.

Notes: These studies examined the influence of learned flavor cues on daily food intake in 28, normal-weight adults. Subjects were trained to associate distinctly flavored high or low calorie lunches with their postingestive effects. Following training, the flavors in the lunches were switched. Twenty-five percent of subjects (responders) adjusted their daily food intake based on their acquired sensory experience and were initially misled by the changes in the flavor cues; i.e., following the flavor switch, responders consumed additional or fewer calories based on the expected rather than actual energy intake of the meals. Energy intake gradually returned to baseline levels. The remaining subjects (nonresponders) were not misled by the flavor switch and maintained their customary level of intake. Responses were more pronounced following conditioning with the high calorie as compared to the low-calorie lunch. These data suggest that sensory cues may play an important role in the control of long-term food intake in individuals who are sensitive to such training.

Notes: A base syrup formulation containing nonvolatile flavor compounds was used to systematically evaluate the sensory contributions of selected volatile compounds (Furaneol, 2,5–dimethyl-4-hydroxy-3(2H)-furanone; sugar furanone, 4,5-dimethyl-3-hydroxy-2(5H)-furanone; guaiacol, 2-methoxy phenol; vanillin, 4-hydroxy-3-methoxy-benzaldehyde) to maple syrup flavor. Descriptive sensory panels showed that all compounds contributed to maple flavor intensity, but sugar furanone was an exceptionally important determinant. Medium and dark amber syrups contained generally higher concentrations of the selected flavor compounds than the light amber syrup. 5′-Inosine monophosphate was tentatively identified in maple syrup by HPLC analysis, and was found to contribute important taste characteristics to maple syrup. Consumer studies showed that more flavorful, darker grade A syrups were preferred over light amber grade A syrup.

Notes: A panel of trained sensory judges is a sensitive and valuable instrument. and a lot of time and work is invested in their selection and training. The importance of internal motivation and external stimulation to maintain the interest and wellbeing of these human instruments is supported by major food scientists and behavioral psychologists. Current stimulation procedures for sensory judges are listed. A new procedure is proposed, consisting of an annual celebration party on November 20 in recognition of sensory judges. Advantages of holding this day on an international level are discussed: mainly, promotion of fellowship among sensory judges from different groups and countries, and also its help in increasing cooperation in sensory evaluation. Actions to promote International Sensory Judges Day are listed. Suggestions for the actual celebration party are put forward: an open house luncheon, presentation of awards, greeting cards and letters from other sensory panels; and last but not least, a set of proven “sensory” games where everyone joins in.

Notes: This research characterized the time-intensity (TI) profiles of monosodium glutamate (MSG), disodium 5′-inosinate (IMP), and disodium 5′-guanylate (GMP). Twenty subjects rated total taste intensity of single solutions of 2.5, 5 and 10 mM MSG, 0.63 and 2.5 mM IMP and GMP, and some of their mixtures, using the TI method. The profiles generated were atypical of other taste modalities. Time to maximum intensity waslong (16–20s), followed by a plateau at maximum intensity, and a persistent aftertaste (50–96s duration). Maximum intensities of the samples varied (p 〈 0.001), with mixtures of 10 and 5 mM MSG with 2.5 mM IMP or GMP yielding the highest intensities. Similar differences were found for total duration and area under the curve. These results indicate that flavor potentiators may increase total flavor during consumption. Synergism between flavor potentiators was demonstrated.

Notes: Different goat cheeses from Chile were studied by Free-Choice Profile (FCP) analysis. Generalized Procrustes Analysis (GPA) applied to FCP data permitted differentiation between samples and informed on the attributes responsible for the observed differences. Appearance was a dominant factor in discriminating samples and to a lesser degree textural variables were also correlated with GPA dimensions. In acceptability the fresh cheeses were significantly preferred over the ripened ones.

Notes: Although expert assessment of food characteristics is recognized as a key step in product development, the use of consumer based measurements is sometimes recommended as an equivalent to the experts. From cognitive psychology, support of the role of perceptual learning is found in some instances, although this could not be relevant in others. To address this point performance analysis of experts and untrained panelists in cheese texture evaluation was carried out. Neither the untrained panelists nor the experts were familiar with either the scales or the kind of cheese. The same Cheddar cheese was given to 44 untrained subjects in three trials to assess hardness. The results showed that their judgment has a 29% average random error variance; the interrater reliability being low. The same experiment gave a random error variance of 2% for three highly skilled judges (experts). The difference in variance was linked to training. Untrained panelists also showed an adaptation error. Nevertheless, there was no significant difference between the average ratings of both groups, whether untrained or experts.

Notes: Previous experiments have shown that the same-different test, because of its more suitable cognitive strategy and lower memory requirements, is a more powerful and sensitive alternative to the triangle and duo-trio tests. This project describes an experiment conducted in order to investigate ways to improve further the performance of the same-different test. Three protocols were compared using orange flavored beverages and 24 judges: the same-different method, the triangle test and the dual-pair paradigm. The latter protocol could improve the same-different's performance by preventing the spontaneous variations of the judges’τ criterion. While no significant differences were detected among the d’ values obtained with each procedure, a trend was observed for the same-different and dual-pair test to be slightly more sensitive (higher d’ values) than the triangle test. Since the same-different test is statistically more powerful, it is a preferable choice over the triangle, duo-trio and dual-pair tests.

Notes: The most widely used scale for assessing food liking or disliking is the 9-pt hedonic scale. Unfortunately, this affective scale suffers from problems related to unequal scale intervals and the underuse of end categories, which results in a reduced ability to differentiate among extremely well liked or extremely disliked foods. Magnitude estimation avoids these problems while enabling ratio statements to be made about the data. However, it does not provide absolute ratings of liking/disliking and can be difficult for some consumers to use. We report here on the development of a labeled affective magnitude scale (LAM) scale that has advantages over both the 9-pt hedonic scale and magnitude estimation. Forty-four semantic labels were scaled for their affective meaning by subjects using modulus-free magnitude estimation. The geometric mean magnitude estimates obtained for each semantic label were used to construct a series of labeled affective magnitude scales by spacing the labels along a visual analogue scale according to their obtained semantic values. Reliability and sensitivity studies were conducted to assess the effects of alternative semantic and numeric labels. The results of these studies led to the choice of a scale format that uses verbal labels that are consistent with the 9-pt hedonic scale. The labeled affective magnitude (LAM) scale was compared to the hedonic scale and magnitude estimation in several food preference and acceptability tests. The LAM was shown to have equal reliability and sensitivity to the hedonic scale, provided somewhat greater discrimination among highly liked foods, and resulted in data that were similar to magnitude estimation in terms of the obtained ratios among rated stimuli. The LAM scale was also judged by consumers to be as easy to use as the 9-pt hedonic scale and significantly less difficult than magnitude estimation.

Notes: Contextual shifts were observed for sweetness of a fruit beverage and for estimated tactile roughness of sandpapers. Midrange stimuli were judged to be less intense in the context of stronger items and more intense in the context of weaker items, a contrast effect. The use of a reference standard decreased the size of the contrast shift for the labeled magnitude scale but not for magnitude estimation.

Notes: The effect of liking, brand and price label on purchase intention were studied on crisp snacks in branded, supermarket own label and economy form. Unlabeled assessment segregated the products into differing levels of liking which did not correspond to marketed price and brand location. Level of liking dominated purchase intention under partial label (price or brand alone) and full label (price with brand) conditions. Relative and derived purchase intention measures gave clearer label effects with significance for brand and price. Consumers who professed higher price awareness were more influenced by price, but those professing brand as a main purchase intention reason gave more weight to liking. Results from analysis of purchase intention and degree of liking measures according to private body conscious level were inconclusive.

Notes: Reaction Time (RT) procedures are widely used in cognitive and behavioral experiments. In the sensory realm RT has been traditionally applied to measure visual, auditory or motor responses. The application of the RT method to gustatory stimuli has proved to be difficult. Attempts to develop automatic control techniques have been restrained by difficulties related to the control of variables, e.g. physiochemical characteristics of chemical solutions and the procedure for stimulus presentation. In this report we describe a computer based system that was designed to measure the reaction time to taste solutions dropped on the tongue. The equipment consists of a pumping system, an interface between the computer and the pumping system, the software required to control the interface and to measure reaction time, and a push button to detect the subject's response. The system can be used as a tool for both research and evaluation tests.

Notes: Caffeine contributes to the flavor profiles of beverage and food products, and other bitter compounds, such as quinine, cannot replicate caffeine's bitterness. Research also has indicated caffeine's ability to enhance desirable tastes, such as sweetness and saltiness, in beverages by modifying neurological pathways. Caffeine may reduce potential “ off-flavors” by solubilizing some compounds, while having little effect on other compounds considered important in beverage flavor profiles. Exposure to caffeine may enhance cognition and potentially heighten the capacity for smell and taste. Thus, use of caffeine in beverages may positively affect flavor profiles and the experience of beverage consumption.

Notes: The aim of the present work was to study the sensorial characteristics of Los Pedroches cheese after freezing, monitoring the effects of the speed and time of frozen storage. Changes were observed in the hardness, creaminess and eyes of cheeses after 3-months frozen storage. The paste hardened, becoming less creamy, and the number and size of the eyes decreased substantially. However, these attributes remained unchanged during storage periods of up to 9 months. Odor, flavor intensity, acidity and grainy were modified as a consequence of frozen storage. The speed of the freezing process only affected the grainy of the cheese; this was greater in slowly-frozen cheeses.

Notes: A lexicon for describing the flavor of wheat sourdough bread (WSB) was developed. A highly trained, descriptive sensory panel identified, defined, and referenced 32 flavor attributes for WSB. To determine the flavor characteristics of WSB, 37 samples were selected or prepared to represent a wide range of both commercial and laboratory variations. Crust and crumb of sourdough bread had different flavor properties; thus, they were evaluated separately. Twenty six attributes described the characteristics of sourdough bread crumb, and 28 attributes described the characteristics of crust. Some attributes were found in most or all samples, but many attributes were found in only one or a few samples. All 37 samples had distinctly different flavor attributes and intensities in both crumb and crust samples. The principal components analysis for crumb and crust indicated that the number of attributes could not be reduced into a smaller set of components that completely described the wide range of breads used in this study. However, reducing the number of attributes measured might be possible when only a few WSB samples are evaluated.

Notes: This research examined the sensory characteristics of craved and aversive foods, as determined by 70 healthy adults. Cravings and aversions were identified by 66% and 53% of subjects. Typically, cravings were intermittent, and the items were sweet tasting and pleasant smelling. In contrast, aversions were chronic, and the items were described as either bitter or bad (e.g., soapy, mealy, dusty) tasting, and exhibiting an unpleasant smell. Chemesthetic attributes were frequently associated with cravings and aversions, particularly texture and thermal sensations with the former whereas texture and irritating sensations were associated with the latter. The findings suggest that sensory characteristics of foods may provide salient cues for the formation of cravings and aversions.

Notes: The commonly used approach to psychophysical taste descriptive analysis called ‘taste profiling’was assessed to determine whether it produced concept alignment with an agreed set of labels; it did not. After judges had been trained using a concept alignment procedure involving fifty-nine standards, the procedure was assessed to see whether broadly defined concepts of ‘sweet’, ‘sour’, ‘salty’and ‘bitter’generalized to various stimuli; they did not. It was concluded that the technique is inferior to currently used methods of descriptive analysis.

Notes: Many factors contribute to the total perception of a food product. The visual packaging attributes of products can be considered important by contributing to their “ on the shelf” presentation which predisposes consumers to purchase. Such extrinsic product packaging attributes can be considered appearance stimuli and thus differ from the intrinsic sensory attributes of a product only in that the packaging attributes are judged by sight and not using the other senses of mouthfeel, olfaction and gustation during consumption. A new approach to measuring product packaging attributes could be to use descriptive sensory analysis. In order to attempt this, 15 assessors, trained in descriptive analysis procedures generated individual vocabularies to describe Cheddar cheeses’ packaging attributes using the repertory grid method. Vocabulary development sessions were subsequently carried out, during which assessors agreed on a vocabulary of 20 defined packaging attributes. The packaging of 8 Cheddar cheeses was then evaluated using standard descriptive analysis procedures. Analysis of Variance found all attributes to discriminate between the eight cheeses (p〈0.01) and Principal Components Analysis allowed the relationships between cheeses and packaging attributes to be viewed. The analysis also indicated that assessors agreed with each other on the meaning of the packaging attributes and could reproduce their evaluations. Limitations in the use of this method were also considered, particularly in relation to scaling of some of the attributes, and the potential subjectivity of others. Despite this, the study showed it was possible to apply descriptive techniques to describe the packaging attributes of Cheddar cheese.

Notes: A new ‘bipolar’ R-index analysis was proposed and evaluated. Eighteen judges evaluated red color in eight wine samples by comparing each sample with the control. Judges indicated whether the sample had ‘more’, the 'same’, or ‘less’ red color than the control, and whether they were sure or unsure of their decision. Three computational methods were used to examine the results: the ‘traditional’ R-index, the ‘bipolar’ R-index (Rmore or Rless) and the ‘weighted-bipolar’ R-index. While all three methods provided consistent results, the ‘bipolar’ R-indices reflected bidirectional differences among the samples thus providing more information. A refinement to the computation (‘weighted-bipolar’ R-index) was an approach for eliminating the bias associated with overestimation of the sample size and accordingly changed some of the significance levels. Further research is currently underway to expand the scope and application of this method.

Notes: In his article “ On Fitting Equations to Sensory Data.” Moskowitz suggests many strategies for model fitting which depart from current statistical methodology. Four areas discussed by Moskowitz are addressed here: (1) Forcing terms into a model; (2) The use of hold-out samples; (3) The use of aggregate data (averaging across people, suppressing the person-to-person variation); and (4) The use of random data as a predictor variable in a regression equation. All four of these points will be examined within this article.

Notes: Extruded puffed corn starch was equilibrated to various water activities over saturated salt solutions. After equilibration the samples were stored in sealed containers for a period of eight weeks. A trained descriptive sensory panel determined the textural characteristics of the samples, after equilibration and after eight weeks of storage. The critical water activity, the water activity at which the textural characteristics of the samples significantly changed was determined to be between water activities 0.36-0.58. Principal component analysis showed that samples equilibrated to water activities above the critical water activity (0.36) were perceived to be low in fracturability and high in cohesiveness.

Notes: The aim of this work was to select a competent sensory panel considering its ability to describe ewes milk cheese sensory properties. The panelists evaluated the sensory characteristics of several ewes milk cheeses in terms of odor, flavor and texture. The performance of judges was assessed taking into account the following aspects: (1) individual discriminatory ability and reproducibility for each sensory attribute; (2) group discriminatory ability and reproducibility and agreement between judges for each attribute; (3) panel homogeneity; (4) panel consonance; and (5) overall panel discriminatory ability. The panel performance was checked with a set of statistical procedures. The results obtained by the selected group were better than the initial panel from the point of view of discriminant power, reproducibility and agreement. The suggested method can be easily applied in routine control of assessors performance and to discover deviant behavior or differences in individual perception of the samples.

Notes: Currently no standard testing methods exist for finished products eliciting oral heat. In this study, descriptive sensory analysis was used to investigate the effects of rinsing and interstimulus time on measurements of capsaicin heat in tomato-based salsa at three oral locations (tongue, oral cavity, throat). Seven samples were tested daily with variations in intervals between stimuli (30 s, 1, 2, 4, 8, and 16 min) and with or without rinsing (crackers and water). Rinsing significantly increased repeatability and increased the rate of heat decay across all loci. An exponential heat decay was observed. Tongue heat was significantly higher than oral cavity and throat burn, and slight sensitization and desensitization occurred with short and long interstimulus times, respectively. This study showed that seven samples of medium-heat salsa could be tested daily with at least 16 min between samples and liberal rinsing with crackers and water.

Notes: The present study examined the effect of two different processing technologies in the manufacture of a ewe's-milk cheese. Two batches were manufactured, one from raw milk, the other from pasteurized milk. A starter culture consisting of Lactococcus lactis subsp. lactis var. diacetylactis and Lactobacillus casei subsp. casei was added to both batches. Descriptive analysis of the sensory characteristics was carried out for the two cheese batches at two different ripening times (90 and 180 days).Statistical analysis revealed differences both between the two batches and between the ripening times considered. The cheeses made from the raw milk were firmer, with a more characteristic odor, taste, and aftertaste. The cheeses made from the pasteurized milk were creamier with a sweeter odor and taste and a more bitter aftertaste. Irrespective of the cheese batch, at 180 days all the cheese samples were firmer and grainier with a more characteristic taste and aftertaste as well as a spicier taste and aftertaste.

Notes: The aim of this work was to develop a new modeling method of time-intensity curves by utilizing the simple shape of a trapezoid. Using a computerized procedure, time-intensity data were collected from panelists evaluating sensory attributes of ice creams. The method was based on the extraction of four values on the time axis, corresponding to 5 and 90% of the maximum intensity value, both in the increasing and decreasing phases of the curve. These intensity levels were chosen because they permitted to rub out some artifacts for intensities close to zero and in the maximum intensity plateau region. Kinetic parameters (duration and rate of the increasing and decreasing phases of the sensation, duration of the maximum intensity) were calculated from the coordinates of the trapezoid, allowing to differentiate ice creams. They were found to bring complementary information in comparison with traditional intensity scaling. In the present paper, the fat content was identified as modifier of the maximum fruitiness intensity of ice creams and of the kinetic of flavor release.

Notes: Research on the power of discrimination methods in difference and preference tests has both theoretical and practical significance. Power is important to evaluate the sensitivities of tests and determine sample size. Ennis and Bi (1998, 1999) proposed the beta-binomial distribution to model replicated difference and preference tests with inter-trial variation and analyzed in general the power of the tests. In this paper, the power of discrimination methods for replicated difference and preference tests is discussed further. The equations for calculating power for methods based on the BB model are given. Examples with tables and charts for calculating and comparing the power of the methods are also given.

Notes: Ennis and Bi (1998) discussed the beta-binomial (BB) model for replicated difference and preference tests. Based on the BB model, tables of the minimum number of choice responses to achieve significance at α≦ 0.05 are provided for replicated 2-AFC, Duo-Trio, 3-AFC and Triangular tests. The theory underlying the tables, how to use the tables, as well as some examples to illustrate their use are given. The tables can be used to evaluate the results of replicated difference and preference tests using forced choice methods.

Notes: This paper describes an initial but fundamental attempt to lay some groundwork for a fuzzy-set-based paradigm for sensory analysis and to demonstrate how fuzzy set and neural network techniques may lead to a natural way for sensory data interpretation. Sensory scales are described as fuzzy sets, sensory attributes as fuzzy variables, and sensory responses as sample membership grades. Multi-judge responses are formulated as a fuzzy membership vector or fuzzy histogram of response, which gives an overall panel response free of the unverifiable assumptions implied in conventional approaches. Neural networks are used to provide an effective tool for modeling and analysis of sensory responses in their naturally fuzzy and complex forms. A maximum method of defuzzification is proposed to give a crisp grade of the majority opinion. Two applications in meat quality evaluation are used to demonstrate the use of the paradigm and procedure. It is hoped that this work will bring up some new ideas and generate interest in research on application of fuzzy sets and neural networks in sensory analysis.

Notes: A statistical method for analyzing sensory profiling data obtained by means of fixed vocabulary or free choice profiling is discussed. The most interesting feature of this method is that it involves only simple statistical treatment and can therefore be performed using standard software packages. The outcomes of this method are compared to those of Generalized Procrustes Analysis on the basis of two data sets obtained, respectively, by means of fixed vocabulary and free choice profiling. A significance test is also discussed in order to assess whether the overall configuration of the products is meaningful. This significance test is based upon a simulation study involving the permutation procedure.

Notes: Monadic (one sample served at a time, and all attributes rated for that sample) and simultaneous multiple (4 samples served together, and attributes rated one at a time across samples) presentation and evaluation procedures were compared in terms of descriptive profile generated, panel performance (ability to discriminate, reproducibility, concept alignment) and session duration, in a descriptive analysis of 9 milk chocolate samples by a panel of 18 trained judges. The sensory profiles obtained with the two presentation modes were very similar (as assessed by spider web and principal component plots). Time-wise, the simultaneous presentation procedure took significantly longer to complete (p〈0.001). Judges discriminated slightly better and were more reproducible with the simultaneous presentation mode, but quality of concept alignment did not differ between the two procedures. We conclude each method has its advantages and limitations, and choice of presentation procedure should be based on the type of descriptive analysis carried out and the time frame available.

Notes: There are many ways in which a laboratory difference test differs from ‘real life’discrimination of foods. One of these is the interval of time between tasting the two stimuli to be discriminated. To investigate this, Cubero et al. (1995) investigated interstimulus delays of up to 1 min. for the same-different test, using a citrus flavored beverage as a medium. The present study extended this research by increasing the interstimulus delays up to 1 day. For judges unfamiliar with the stimuli, performance deteriorated as the time interval increased. For judges more familiar with the stimuli, performance deteriorated but not as much. The results were compatible with Cubero et al.'s hypothesis that different types of memory trace for the first (standard) stimulus were utilized for comparison with the second (comparison) stimulus.

Notes: Pork patties from Musculus semimembranosus, were utilized by a sensory panel to develop a descriptive vocabulary for the sensory profiling of warmed-over flavor. Patties were derived from the meat of nonstressed and stressed animals and were stored at 4C for up to 5 days. An initial list containing 45 descriptive terms developed from the literature and a preliminary sample evaluation was presented to the panel. This list was modified over a 7 session period to 16 terms each with a corresponding reference material. Selection criteria were that terms should; have relevance to the product, discriminate clearly between samples, be nonredundant, and have cognitive clarity to the assessors. Criteria fulfillment was determined via representative sample and reference assessment, panel discussions and interpretation of Principal Component Analysis. During vocabulary development the panel showed dynamic changes in their use of the sensory vocabulary. Discriminative abilities were found to increase over the early sessions and appeared to stabilize in the final two sessions.

Notes: A sensory panel utilized chicken patties from Pectoralis major muscle to develop a descriptive vocabulary for warmed-over flavor. Patties were subjected to 4 different cooking temperatures and stored at 4C for up to 4 days. A list of 33 descriptive terms, developed from the literature and a preliminary sample evaluation was modified over 5 daily sessions to 18 terms with corresponding references. In the term selection process the criteria used were, that terms should; have relevance to the product, discriminate clearly between samples, be nonredundant, and have cognitive clarity to the assessors. A comprehensive vocabulary was developed that described the sensory dimensions present in the samples. Over sessions the panel was found to display dynamic changes in their use of the sensory vocabulary. Overall, panel discriminative abilities were enhanced and a process of sensory learning was observed.

Notes: Using a Rank-Rating method, d’values were obtained for stimuli from a model system using 15-point, 9-point, 7-point and 5-point category scales. For an apple/grape juice system, d’values were compared for 9-point and 7-point scales. There was general agreement on d’values among the scales, except where stimuli had their scores ‘bunched’into one category: this tended to occur for the strongest and weakest stimuli for Rank-Rating and for the scales with fewer points. Bunching altered distribution variances and distorted the calculated d’values. Further study gave d’values for the discrimination of confusable stimuli, using paired-comparison and rating data, thus providing numerical measures of their relative sensitivity.

Notes: In a recent paper Moskowitz (1996) refuted the notion that consumers are incapable of validly rating the sensory aspects of products. An analysis of this paper reveals that references are not presented to support his introduction, there is lack of experimental detail, parameters to compare panels were questionable, the degree of expertise of the expert panel is put to doubt and the model proposed to relate data between panels was not compared to existing models.

Notes: Mayonnaise is microbiologically stable, thus its shelf-life is determined by the change in its sensory properties, mainly flavor changes due to oxidative rancidity of its main component, oil. The effect of storage temperature, fat content and type of package on the shelf-life of a commercial mayonnaise was studied. Sensory descriptors with corresponding references are presented. The sensory descriptors which varied with storage time were: total aroma, and for flavor: egg, oily and oxidized. Rate of oxidized flavor change was greater in whole fat than in low fat mayonnaise. For 10 cm3 pouches, package related flavors were developed during storage. Shelf-life ± confidence interval for whole fat mayonnaise was 184 ± 18, 24 ± 9 and 20 ± 5 days at 20, 35 and 45C, respectively. Development of oxidized flavor followed a zero order reaction rate, activation energy was 15 kcal/mol.

Notes: A descriptive analysis panel was trained to use a refined lexicon of flavor descriptors to evaluate farm-raised catfish flavor using a referenced intensity rating scale. To reduce variance due to within sample variability, a procedure using Blended Individual Fish Samples (BIFS) was developed. The reproducibility of the panel performance, utility of the BIFS and the sensitivity of the method to discriminate differences in fish flavor was demonstrated in three experiments.

Notes: When choosing a design for estimating product differences we must consider both the appropriate model for the analysis of results and the economic aspects of the test. If no residual effects are expected the SMD design provides an efficient way of estimating the product difference. If the residual effect is known to be present it is better to consider an alternative design. The choice of an alternative will depend on both theoretical (desired precision of estimates) and practical (cost of conducting a study) considerations. In this paper, I review both the theoretical underpinnings of SMD and some of its possible alternatives.

Notes: Recent studies comparing magnitude estimation to other scaling methods have been criticized for failure to submit the data to logarithmic transformation before statistical analysis, a procedure which can improve the ability of magnitude estimation scaling to differentiate among products. Data from one of these studies was available for re-analysis, which was conducted both with and without logarithmic transformation of magnitude estimation, category scales and line scales. The ability of magnitude estimation to differentiate among products was improved by log transformation, while the other methods were not. Improvements were associated in pan with reductions in positive skew and improved approximation of the normal distribution. In spite of this improvement, magnitude estimation remained slightly inferior to the other methods especially in the hands of an untrained consumer sample.

Notes: Using a model system of 3mM NaCl and purified water, predictions were made for subjects’ability to discriminate the odd sample in a set of nine triadic tasting sequences associated with the triangle test. With such individual triads rather than triangular testing protocols which involve more than one triad, it was found necessary to modify the regular Sequential Sensitivity Analysis. The modification required a consideration of sensory adaptation effects caused by repeated tasting of the same stimulus in some of the sequences. Further confirmation was also obtained for the order of magnitude of signal strengths of water and NaCl stimuli tasted after water or NaCl prerinses.

Notes: The efficiencies of incomplete block designs were investigated by comparing two hundred and twenty eight analyses from eleven trials using hedonic scales with corresponding randomized complete block analyses. Of the ten explanatory factors examined, only the panelist, the product type, the number of samples per session and the average score of the data had an effect on the efficiency of incomplete block designs. The effect of product type was attributed to influences of produce consumed outside the trial, and the effect of the data mean reflected decreased conscientiousness with products the panelists disliked. With three and four samples per session, incomplete block designs were 31 % and 2 % more efficient, respectively, than randomized complete block designs. When five or more samples were tested, the incomplete block designs were markedly less efficient. The practical implications of all these effects on experimental design are discussed.

Notes: Aroma properties of twenty-three branched-chain, odd-numbered, or unsaturated fatty acids which had each been dispersed in acidic aqueous media (pH 2.0) were evaluated. Aroma threshold values were determined using approximately 95 judges for assessing the presence of aromas over dilutions of each fatty acid. Qualitative aroma threshold values for individual fatty acids ranged from 0.006 to 82.4 ppm in the acidic solutions, and 4-ethyloctanoic acid exhibited the lowest threshold of the group tested. Qualitative aroma assessments of dilutions of each fatty acid showed a wide range of unique aroma properties. Fatty acids exhibiting branching at the 4-position had goaty/muttony/sheepy aroma notes as did other fatty acids containing 8-carbon chain structures. Cheese-like aromas were associated with the shorter branched-chain fatty acids.

Notes: In the running of consumer studies aimed at obtaining information about products and services, it has become increasingly popular to include some sensory type questions about the characteristics of the test product as well as the standard question about overall preference. The implications of this for the resultant data are complex, and as Sudman and Schwarz (1989) point out question order effects have been implicated as one of the major causes of unreplicated or unexpected findings in survey research. This study aims to establish the effect of question order on overall preference scores and sensory scores in consumer studies. Results indicate that there is a significant effect of asking sensory questions on overall preference ratings and the position of the preference questions (relative to the sensory questions) also has implications for overall ratings of preference.

Notes: d′ is an estimate of δ, a measure of the degree of sensory difference between two products, that can be obtained easily using tables, from the proportion of difference tests performed correctly. Tables of δ are available for the 2-AFC, 3-AFC, triangular and duo-trio tests. Tables for calculating the variance of d′ for these tests are provided in this paper. They can be used for comparison of d's, especially for those obtained from different difference tests. A simple procedure is described here for computing values for the variance of d′. Having obtained the variance, confidence intervals for d′ can be obtained, tests of significance for d′ can be made as well as tests of whether two or more d's are significantly different. The formula and tables for the number of judgments required for the estimation of δ are given also in this paper.

Notes: Individuals differ in what they like, both from a sensory basis, but also from a conceptual basis. For a product to be purchased, the concept (or even the flavor name) must be acceptable just as the physical product itself must be acceptable. This paper presents the results of a study in which the panelists rated degree of interest in 12 different new flavors for a snack chip positioned at the start of the study to have a “taste of the southwest.” The results show the substantial variation in acceptance for the different flavors presented as names only (viz., concepts, rather than actual products). Segmentation by attitude of consumers on the basis of the pattern of liking revealed differences among consumers, but did not show the typical opposing patterns found when sensory segmentation is done using actual products having different flavors. These individual differences require that a line of different flavors be developed. There is no simple organizing principle, however, underlying the individual differences. Thus to create the line of flavors requires a different approach. The approach selects various combinations of flavors, identifies the proportion of consumers who would accept at least one flavor of the line (so-called “satisfied consumer”), and then maximizes the number of such “satisfied consumers” for a line comprising a given number of flavors.

Notes: In sensory data sets, an important source of differences between panelists is in their use of the measurement scale. These differences can be summarized in differences in location, the overall level, and differences in dispersion, the range of the scale used. This paper discusses a method of correcting for these differences by jointly modeling location and dispersion using a see-saw algorithm. This approach is also applicable when scores are not normally distributed and when there is a (nonlinear) relationship between the dispersion and the location. The approach is illustrated with an example for flavor data of freeze-dried and hot-air dried peppers.

Notes: It is frequently impossible to meet the assumptions underlying the statistical approach to classification of food products by a sensory panel. To find an alternative, we have investigated the applicability of the fuzzy set theory. Within a fuzzy set framework it is acceptable that a product belongs to several classes simultaneously and no assumptions regarding the distribution of sensory properties for a product class are made. Fuzzy classification models can be constructed from a set of training objects by linking the soft class labels to the sensory attributes applying an inference procedure based on fuzzy logic. A number of fuzzy inference procedures has been evaluated using a number of attribute sets. A satisfactory classification has been found using a very simple implication rule and a set of three attributes.

Notes: Book Reviews in this Article:Quality Assurance of Food Ingredients, Processing and Distribution.Recent Advances in Chemistry and Technology of Fats and Oils.

Notes: A computerized time intensity procedure was used to evaluate the retronasal aroma intensity of vanillin and limonene in oil/water emulsion. The maximum perceived retronasal intensity of limonene was decreased as oil content in the emulsion increased, but temporal perception (time to maximum intensity and total duration of perception) was not affected. Total duration of vanillin retronasal aroma increased as oil content increased, and salivary flow rate had a significant effect on perception of vanillin aroma. These results suggest that time intensity measurements may be a valuable tool for evaluating the effects of matrix interactions on retronasal aroma intensity.

Notes: Paired comparison and triangle tests were used to contrast the effects of ingestion and expectoration in two distinct systems: added salt in kidney beans and nonfat milk with added milkfat. Probit analysis was used to determine panel difference thresholds. Analysis of variance was used to evaluate significant differences between the methods of sampling and for effects of fatigue due to ingestion of the sample. No significant differences between the two methods of sampling were found for either thresholds or fatigue effects.

Notes: The concept of free-choice profiling allows untrained assessors to participate in sensory profiling. However, it is sometimes the case that such individuals are unable to describe what they perceive when the samples are presented in the isolation of the sensory testing booths. This paper reports an experiment to compare the usual free-choice profile procedure, with a more structured approach based on Kelly's repertory grid method. Generalized Procrustes analysis was used to analyse the data. The sample configurations obtained from both approaches were very similar, as were the interpretations of the main perceptual dimensions.

Notes: A novel experimental method was developed which allows the determination of the threshold concentration of sucrose by use of a linear sucrose gradient in water. With this method a continuous tasting of the test-liquid is possible. A panel of 15 persons experienced in taste-testing was used. Three gradients of different steepness were applied: 0 to 1.5% (w/w) sucrose in 2 min (I), 3 min (II) and 4 min (III). The results of the new method were compared with those of the standard method (DIN). With gradients I and II we found values which were significantly higher than those of the standard method (I: 0.49% (w/w); II: 0.46% (w/w); DIN: 0.31% (w/w)), whereas with gradient III the same threshold value was found as with the DIN-Method (III: 0.32% (w/w)).

Notes: The effects of two doses (2.0 and 3.5 kGy) of nonradioactive irradiation on flavor, texture and aroma were compared to nonirradiated controls for (1) frozen raw and precooked, ground beef patties with 10 and 22% fat packaged in vacuum or aerobically; (2) frozen, vacuum-packaged, boneless beef steaks; and (3) chilled, vacuum-packaged, boneless, beef steaks that were repackaged in an oxygen-permeable film (PVC) after 14 days of storage. Samples were evaluated by a highly trained descriptive panel for fifteen sensory attributes for ground beef patties and eighteen sensory attributes for whole muscle beef. Irradiation had minimal effects on flavor, texture, and aroma of frozen, raw and precooked, ground beef patties; frozen boneless beef steaks; and vacuum-packaged, chilled, boneless, beef steaks. Reintroduction of oxygen to irradiated beef by repackaging into PVC film after vacuum aging increased liver-like (at 3.5 kGy) and toughness (at 2.0 kGy) attributes and slightly decreased beef identity and browned/roasted flavor notes (at 2.0 kGy.)

Notes: Fully integrating sensory resources with related business units represents a challenge for the sensory professional. As sensory evaluation provides actionable information in a timely, cost effective manner, developing resources that are consistent with corporate plans and impact on decision-making is essential. This discussion focuses on developing a sensory strategy for success and highlights strategic planning techniques designed to maximize sensory evaluation's contribution to the accomplishment of a company's mission.

Notes: Classical techniques of descriptive sensory analysis are useful in food characterization. However, these methods need trained assessors and an agreed vocabulary. Free Choice Profiling may be regarded as a good alternative as it allows descriptive profiles to be carried out with untrained assessors, although certain problems may arise in the generation of descriptors and their interpretation. The descriptive profiles, regarding different lots of toasted almonds, generated by a panel of semi-trained assessors and by a panel of expert assessors were compared. The resulting descriptors were basically the same for both panels. The semi-trained assessors generated less specific and, sometimes, ambiguous and redundant descriptors. The expert assessors showed a higher efficiency in the generation of descriptors, especially regarding texture. Both profiles were graphically similar, though a deeper analysis showed that only the expert assessors were able to discriminate very similar products. Using a panel of semi-trained assessors solves the main problems which arise when consumers are used in free choice profiling. However, both panels are not capable of discriminating very similar products.

Notes: The objective of this study was to determine if higher fiber levels in a food contributed to greater sensory specific satiety. Thirty-two subjects tasted and rated their liking of small samples of nine foods (including the test food) before and after a test meal. Test meals consisted of 500 kcal (2092 kJ) of a soup or a muffin. Both a high-fiber (10g) and low-fiber (1g) version of a soup and a muffin were tested. High-fiber versions contained added microcrystalline cellulose. Data from the soup and muffin treatments were analyzed separately. Each of the test meals resulted in a greater decrease in liking for the food eaten versus the uneaten foods. However, there was no increase in sensory specific satiety for the high-fiber treatments versus the low-fiber treatments. There was also no main effect for gender.

Notes: The taste quality of 27 stimuli equi-intense to 100 mM NaCl was described by 10 subjects using cross-modality matching with Munsell colors. Subjects were instructed to use one color for each perceived taste quality. An initial set of 9 stimuli covering the range of taste qualities was used by the subjects to build their own spectrum of colors to match taste qualities. Subjects then used their system to describe the quality of 18 sweet and/or bitter stimuli. All subjects were able to develop and consistently use Munsell colors to describe taste quality. This psychophysical method for taste description could allow for a better discrimination among taste stimuli than the traditional use of five adjectives. Three-dimensional plots in L, a, b coordinates of the color spaces produced by the subjects suggest sweetness and bitterness may not be unitary qualities, and that semantics may not be sufficient to describe taste quality.

Notes: Although extrusion is widely used for snack foods, there are few descriptive sensory analysis studies of extrudates. This study investigated the effects of potato granule type (flour or flakes), feed moisture content (16%, 18% and 20%) and addition of oil (0%, 2% and 4%) on sensory attributes of extrudates. Generalized Procrustes analysis (GPA) and Principal Component analysis (PCA) were used to describe the relationship among the sensory attributes. Additionally, GPA described the relationship between selected sensory and physical variables. Feed moisture content, as a primary factor, and added oil, as the secondary, affected the puff characteristics. High feed moisture puffs were high in hardness and chewiness, whereas low moisture ones were high in brownness, burnt flavor and fracturability. Added oil changed sensory expansion with relation to low feed moisture. Using GPA, physical properties related to appearance, color and texture were matched with corresponding sensory attributes.

Notes: This study examined the contributions of stimulus fat content and flavor volatiles to the perception of fat in a milk model system. The model system was formulated by adding bland vegetable oil (0%, 5%, or 10% w/v) and natural cream flavor (0%, 0.5% or 1% w/v) to a skim milk base. Panelists judged pairs of samples for similarity on the basis of three attributes (fat content, mouthcoating and thickness) and the results were analyzed using a multidimensional scaling procedure. Two-dimensional solutions best represented the data. The stimulus spaces for fat content and mouthcoating were visually similar to each other and provided reasonable separation of the samples. Instrumental measures helped to define the underlying dimensions of the stimulus space for fat content. Dimension 1 related to texture and included the contributions of viscosity, and fat particle size and number distribution; dimension 2 related to flavor perception. The sample with a moderate fat content (5%) and the highest concentration of added cream flavor (1%) was perceived to be similar to the 10% fat samples with added flavor. Thus, the added flavor provided the sensation of higher fat content. These data suggest that flavor plays an important role in the preception of fat in dairy foods. A psychophysical model of fat perception in dairy foods is proposed which includes the contribution of viscosity, fat particle size and number distribution, and volatile flavor perceptions.

Notes: Consumers want meat products that are healthful and affordable. However, consumers will repurchase a product only if it tastes good. Consumers identified reasons for purchasing frankfurters and evaluated overall acceptability of 10 commercially available frankfurters. Consumers listed “taste” as the most important factor when purchasing frankfurters; only 16% of the consumers indicated that nutrition/health was the most important criterion. Nineteen consumer-perceived sensory and liking attributes were measured for the frankfurters in this study. The intensities of the attributes ranged from low to moderately high. All the frankfurters scored in the low to moderate range for overall acceptability. Most of the scores for liking of individual attributes correlated highly with overall liking, indicating that many of the questions relating to attribute liking could be eliminated.

Notes: Sensory research on kiwifruit has shown that specific sugars and acids, and volatile flavor compounds have causative effects on “sweet” and “acid” aroma and flavor attributes. New Zealand consumers (n = 162) assessed the perceived flavor intensity and acceptability of three volatile flavor compounds (ethyl butanoate, E-2-hexenal and hexanal) at varying levels in a model base solution. Increasing levels of ethyl butanoate positively affected all the acceptability attributes (“overall liking,”“liking of aroma,”“liking of flavor”) as well as increased the perceived intensity of “kiwifruit aroma” and “kiwifruit flavor.” Increasing levels of E-2-hexenal negatively affected all the acceptability attributes but increased the perceived intensity of “kiwifruit aroma” and “acid flavor.” An increase in hexanal increased perceived intensity of “kiwifruit aroma.” Ethyl butanoate and E-2-hexenel at the levels tested had the most prominent effects on consumer perceived intensity and acceptability of the “kiwifruit flavor.”

Notes: Since producer based sensory analysis of wine appellations remains in widespread use worldwide by wineries, modern sensory methods were developed for industry judge panels. U.S. appellations were studied using modern sensory analysis processes which accommodated the industry professionals’ biases for perceived quality and provincial sensory language. A panel was assembled comprised of wine industry quality experts (n = 26). First, judge quality biases were determined using a multi-wine preference-testing method (n = 48) in which judges freely record their aroma terms. Subsequently QDA° type strategies were used to create the sensory language from analysis of 1100 wine X judge interactions in which free use of terms was used to describe the wines. Next, an experiment analyzed the wines using a new descriptive analysis scorecard which contained the ten most frequently used terms; and scores were computed from the number of times terms were selected by the judges (frequency of use). Groups of sixteen wines, for which the judges had no large negative bias, from the Carneras American Viticutural Areas (AVA), were compared to those from California wine growing regions (Central Coast, Napa and Sonoma). Replicate trials showed Carneras AVA and Central Coast wines clustered in the principal components (PCA) analysis of the sensory data. The detection of regional typicalness by professionals: (1) was linked to their perceived quality bias, (2) was easily detected in high quality wines linked to grape attributes more than to winemaking attributes, and (3) was not possible when judges had determined that perceived wine quality was low. ANOVA and polar spider plot analysis of the clusters indicated that the important aroma attributes of Carneros wines included Citrus and Green Apples/Pears. Lastly, the sensory analysis data was compared to chemical analysis of terpenes for several wines (n = 22). Chardonnay terpene (linalool) concentrations were highly correlated (p 〈 0.01) with the attribute scores for Citrus which was important in the PCA analysis of the sensory data. These sensory processes offer a descriptive analysis process that accommodates the wine industry professional. The method also offers several advantages over flavor profiling methods including the reduction of the potentially confounding problems of “quality” and “standard terms” among industry professionals as well as speed and correlation with chemical analyses.

Notes: A battery of sensory tests is proposed to select potential descriptive panelists. This set of tests is flavor specific. Several abilities are examined: odor and taste recognition, odor memory, discrimination and descriptive capacities. A detailed example of such a battery to select a Camembert cheese descriptive panel is given. The objectives of each test are discussed. Stimuli are chosen to be consistent with the sensory properties which can be perceived in cheese. Score distributions demonstrate the discrimination among candidates for each test. Globally, results show the difficulty to find 20 panelists amongst about a hundred with good scores on each test. The panel leader has to choose the final criteria taking into account whether or not some abilities could be improved by training and whether weak capacities (small deficiencies) in some panel members could be compensated for by other subjects.

Notes: Taste intensity ratings are higher when many low-intensity stimuli are presented than when many high-intensity stimuli are presented. It is investigated whether similar contextual shifts occur for hedonic judgments.Experiment 1 assessed the perceived pleasantness of a heterogeneous stimulus set containing either a large number of quinine (unpleasant context) or sucrose (pleasant context) solutions. In Experiment 2 subjects made hedonic judgments for a set of sucrose solutions. They were classified pre-experimentally as ‘sweet-likers,’‘neutrals,’ or ‘sweet-dislikers.’ Stimulus frequency distributions were positively or negatively skewed. In Experiment 1, hedonic ratings in the pleasant context were lower than those obtained in the unpleasant context. In Experiment 2, no effect of stimulus context was found.It is argued that contextual shifts in hedonic judgments are found only if the stimuli differ substantially along the hedonic dimension. In addition, the subject groups should be homogeneous with regard to preference rank orders, and should be sufficiently large to allow testing with adequate statistical power.

Notes: Although menthol is a common ingredient in pharmaceutical and food products, its sensory properties have not been studied extensively. The objective of this study was to describe and compare the temporal properties of l- and d-menthol. The cooling, burning, and bitterness of two menthol isomers (l-, d-) each at 0.01, 0.02, 0.04, 0.08% (w/v) in aqueous solution were evaluated by 11 trained panelists using time-intensity methodology. The intensity of all three attributes were evaluated continuously from introduction of the sample into the mouth, through expectoration at 10 s, until the termination of the sensation. The l-menthol samples had a greater maximum intensity and longer total duration of cooling and burning sensations than the d-menthol samples. In addition, maximum intensity and total duration of cooling and burn increased with concentration. In contrast, the total duration of the burning sensation was only dependent upon concentration of the l-isomer. Increasing menthol concentration significantly increased maximum intensity and total duration of bitterness for both isomers.

Notes: Sensory analysis has traditionally played a prominent role in quality control for food products. More and more principles from sensory analysis are also applied in the area of food product development, bringing sensory analysis more closely into the domain of marketing. Unfortunately, in practice integration between sensory and marketing practices is far from optimal. Differences in basic orientations between sensory and marketing are a major source contributing to this defective cooperation.Sensory analysis has traditionally been product oriented with an emphasis on internal validity of the test results. Implicitly or explicitly this approach emphasizes the relationships between sensory evaluation and characteristics of the product. Marketing, on the other hand, stresses the external validity of test results: the extent to which test results can be generalized to market behavior. Emphasis on external validity requires an approach to sensory analysis that is fundamentally different from current sensory practice in terms of type of respondents, type of stimuli, scaling procedures adopted and test circumstances.Closer integration between the product and consumer oriented approach to sensory analysis may contribute to the success of product development in the food industry. The literature suggests several factors that may contribute to a more fruitful cooperation between the two approaches to sensory analysis. The company's senior management plays a central role in the achievement of this integration by providing an infrastructure (in terms of personnel, organizational structure and financial resources) that paves the way for closer cooperation.

Notes: Time-Intensity Curves are often summarized by average curves. From these curves TI-parameters are inferred. In this paper a different method is proposed in which the shape of the curves is the central concept. Isotropic scaling factors are computed for each curve. These factors can be tabled and inspected. Often a large number of scaling factors will be computed, which makes it hard to study them in a table. In such cases they can be represented in a plot, for which in this paper PCA is suggested. In this plot a structure in the scaling factors for the different TI-curves may become visible. It is also possible to make a plot in which the homogeneity of the panel of subjects can be studied.

Notes: In order to evaluate the suitability of signal detection theory methods for assessing the discriminability of foods and beverages, the discriminability of two dairy milk products that differed in fat content was measured with two detection-theoretic methods: the single-interval rating method, and the same-different method. The nominal fat contents of the milk products were 0.1 and 1.6%. Measures of discriminability for three observers were derived by fitting receiver operating characteristics (ROCs) based on equal-variance normal models to the ratings of each observer with a procedure that combined jackknifing and maximum-likelihood estimation. The fitted ROCs provided a good fit to the data indicating that the equal-variance models were appropriate for these tasks. The best-fitting estimates of d′ obtained for each task were not significantly different, demonstrating that d′ is a measure of sensitivity that is largely independent of the task from which it is determined. However, estimates of proportion correct obtained for each task were shown to be significantly different.

Notes: A method for the first step in the selection of trained sensory assessors, based on their skill in identifying basic tastes in low concentration solutions, was defined and evaluated. The solutions used were: 0.4 and 0.8% sucrose; 0.03, 0.04 and 0.06% citric acid; 0.08 and 0.15% sodium chloride; 0.02 and 0.03% caffeine. Concentration ranges were found adequate. The criterion for selection was to have over 65% correct answers. Out of 226 candidates who received the test, 141 (62%) were selected. The probability of a candidate having more than a certain percentage of correct answers was calculated. The influence of the dilution water quality on the perception of basic tastes was significant; distilled water was the most adequate.

Notes: Instrumental measurement of color places hue in a 360° continuum, but sensory description of color usually refers to distinct hues — red, green, yellow etc. Color evaluation of “Golden Delicious” apples by both an instrumental method and an experienced sensory panel was conducted to determine if sensory panelists perceive changes of golden apple color in green and yellow hues separately or on a hue continuum from green to yellow. Apple color changed from green to yellow during storage. Two different sensory scoring ballots were used to determine if sensory panelists view color in discrete green and yellow hues or on a green-to-yellow continuum. Data collected from this study demonstrated that sensory panelists can detect the color changes of decreasing greenness, increasing yellowness, and color change from green to yellow in an equal fashion. Hue angle represented the best predictor of sensory color perception.

Notes: Interindividual differences in sweet and bitter taste sensitivity were investigated using time-intensity (TI) measurements and multivariate statistics. TI profiles were obtained in triplicate from 25 subjects for 23 sweet and/or bitter stimuli first matched to be approximately equi-intense to 200 mM NaCl. Sweet stimuli, except for the larger sweeteners, were less persistent, and required less time to reach maximum intensity than bitter stimuli. The results of principal component (PCA) and cluster (CA) analyses of the stimuli X subjects matrices for maximum intensity (Imax), time to maximum intensity (Tmax), total duration (Tdur), and area under the curve (Area) suggest that sweet and bitter stimuli do not share common receptors; and that there are at least two receptor mechanisms each for sweet taste (one for sugars and other small compounds, and the other for large sweeteners) and bitter taste (one for PTC/PROP and one for other bitter compounds).

Notes: Multidimensional scaling (MDS) procedures produce maps of stimulus points, the dimensions of which may be sensory and/or physicochemical attributes. Our objective was to test the efficiencies of a cyclic design and a MDS method in the study of saltiness perception. Two levels of NaCl (0.1% and 0.2%, w/v) were added to two nonionic and two ionic gum solutions prepared to two concentrations. Subjects scaled dissimilarities between pairs of solutions and rated each sample for flavor attributes. Solution pairs were selected using cyclic designs. Repeated measures ANOVA determined that added NaCl was the only significant factor affecting saltiness perception. In contrast, from KYST-2A MDS maps, we concluded that saltiness perception was influenced by gum property, gum concentration, presence of calcium and potassium, and related to binding of the sodium ion (Na+) as determined by23Na nuclear magnetic resonance (NMR) spectroscopy. The MDS cyclic design successfully reduced the number of samples and subjects when using experienced subjects.

Notes: Taste sensations are of primary importance in food flavor. Any attempt to synthesize chemically the flavor of a natural food involves mainly taste active compounds. Many distinct taste sensations can be identified as associated with food compounds. Thirteen different taste sensations are discussed herein. These different taste sensations are differentiated on the basis of stimulus chemistry and peripheral nerve conveying the taste information. Neurophysiological examination of the peripheral nerves involved in taste reveals that the sensory neurons can, in any species, be subdivided into distinct neural groups. These different neural groups respond to distinct classes of chemicals and often display different neurophysiological characteristics. Altogether in four different species, nine functional neural taste groups can be distinguished. In many cases, these neural groups can be taken as analogs for the neural groups assumed to underly human taste sensations. Distinct human taste sensations can be considered to arise from the excitation or inhibition of different neural groups. For certain human taste sensations there are no animal neural analog groups; and for certain neural groups there are no analog human sensations.

Notes: Psychological studies have assessed the intensity of simple sensory mixtures, both in taste and olfaction. In taste mixtures, suppression or partial masking among the components is often observed. An analogous result is often found in odor mixtures, counteraction of one component in the presence of a second odor. These effects, particularly taste suppression, are also observed in food systems. Interactions between sensory modalities are far more complex, ranging from inhibition of taste and odor sensations by trigeminal irritation, to relative independence of tastes from odor stimulation and independence of odors from tastes.

Notes: Gustatory function is not static within an individual. Taste sensitivity and preferences are modified by numerous, well-documented external factors (e. g. smoking) as well as less widely recognized physiologic or internal idiosyncratic attributes such as salivary composition and genetic make-up. In addition, no single gustatory attribute adequately characterizes an individual's taste world. Measures of threshold sensitivity, suprathreshold sensitivity and preference may vary independently necessitating the assessment of each to derive a reliable assessment of an individual's gustatory status. Measures of taste preference, however, appear to hold the greatest predictive power for dietary behavior. Gustatory disorders may be manifest in the following forms: hypergeusia, hypogeusia, dysgeusia, ageusia, food aversions and food cravings. Each of these disorders is defined and, to the extent that information is available, the prevalence, etiology and clinical significance of each is discussed. Following this, a general scheme is presented along with numerous examples for evaluating the potential impact health or nutritional disorders may have on gustatory function. Finally, implications of health and nutritional disorders for applied sensory research are briefly considered.

Notes: A testing procedure was developed to determine the concentration range including an absolute or difference threshold for a compound added to a background medium. Samples were arranged into three groups, each containing a labeled control and three randomly arranged samples. Random samples in each group included an unlabeled control and two samples containing adjacent concentration levels from a series of six increasing concentrations of the added substance. Groups were presented in ascending order by concentration of the added substance. Within each group, panelists rated each sample on a nine-point intensity scale of difference from the labeled control. Group specific psychological errors in judgement were reduced by subtracting the unlabeled controls from the sample scores. Analysis of variance was applied to these data yielding separate estimates of variance for sample scores within groups. Sets of t-tests from paired comparisons were used to construct a confidence statement regarding a threshold interval.

Notes: People can eat a food without having a strong preference for it, and people can prefer a food without eating it. Given this seeming disconnect between attitude and behavior, which type of measure or segment can best be used to profile or identify loyal consumer segments of a food, such as soy? This research compares a usage-based method (heavy-light-nonusers) with a new attitude-based method (seeker-neutral-avoider), and finds that the attitude-based method differentiates purchase-related intentions better than the usage-based method. Implications for profiling consumer taste patterns and consumer segments are provided.

Notes: In a recent paper, we described the development and application of a labeled affective magnitude (LAM) scale for assessing liking/disliking (Schutz and Cardello 2001). Here we present the exact numerical scale-point locations corresponding to the verbal labels of the scale, so that investigators can easily construct the LAM scale for use with either paper or computer-based ballots.

Notes: This article describes an exploration of the concept of ‘oral freshness’ for as far as it is important in oral care. It intends to consider the most important mouth sensations and cognitive connotations, including (but not restricted to) the well-known effect of menthol in toothpaste.Two aspects were given attention:(1) The attributes that together form the concept of oral freshness were investigated using a ‘personal construct approach’(Kelly 1955). This method consists of unbiased, structured interviews with subjects, and ultimately yields attribute dimensions that the subjects have in common.(2) The intensity of the freshness sensation over time was investigated using the Time-Intensity method. Subjects gave repeated freshness judgments every few seconds after the intake of a freshness-related stimulus, and continued to do so after the stimulus had left their mouth. In addition we asked for ‘overall’ freshness judgments directly after the TI-measurements and after 2 months.The results confirm that ‘oral freshness’ is a complex concept. We identified 6 attributes, some of which were perceptual/physiological and some cognitive in nature: ‘water’-ness, cool/cold-ness, taste (menthol-ness), clean-ness, smell, energy (texture and touch, e.g., bubbles). Different persons will generally give different importance weights to each of these 6 attributes.Time-intensity measurements show that temperature, menthol-content and, to some extent, the presence of bubbles (energy) influence the momentous sensation of freshness. It appears, however, that in the way freshness is remembered after a few months, mainly cleanness and taste (menthol-ness) are important. Apparently, people tend to value (temporary) sensory input during the actual freshness experience, but tend to remember the freshness result in the longer run.

Notes: Time-intensity (TI) methodology and a trained panel were used to characterize the perceived bitterness of Yerba mate (YM) Ilex paraguariensis infusions. Two sampling procedures (sip and spit; sip and swallow) and two conditions for residence time in mouth (free or fixed duration of 5 s until spit or swallow) were evaluated.At a fixed duration the maximum bitterness as well as the time to reach it showed a significant YM concentration dependence. No change on bitterness was observed by swallowing or spitting YM infusions except a larger rate of decay of the response (vr) at spit condition. Dynamic bitterness at free sampling time showed that the decision period to spit or swallow the YM infusion approximately duplicated the fixed one of 5 s.

Notes: The effect of fat and fat replacers (FR) on the flavor release from cherry ice cream was investigated. Protein based FR, Simplesse (“S”) and carbohydrate based FR, Litesse (“L”) either partially or completely substituted milk fat in ice cream. Overall and temporal flavor profiles of ice cream during eating were obtained using chemical and sensory analyses. The performance of FR depended on the level of fat it was substituting and the amount of fat present in the ice cream. In the reduced fat ice cream group, both FRs failed to mimic the characteristics of 6% fat ice cream, mainly because of the low retention of cherry flavor. In the full fat ice cream group, the sensory properties of ice cream containing “L” were closer to the full-fat (12%) ice cream than those with “S”. The critical flavor volatile compounds that strongly impact the sensory flavor attributes were identified.

Notes: Response surface methodology was used to optimize formulations of chocolate peanut spread. Thirty-six formulations with varying levels of peanut (25-90%), chocolate (5-70%) and sugar (5-55%) were processed using a three-component constrained simplex lattice design. The processing variable, roast (light, medium, dark) was also included in the design. Response variables, measured with consumers (n = 60) participating in the test, were spreadability, overall acceptability, appearance, color, flavor, sweetness and texture/mouthfeel, using a 9-point hedonic scale. Regression analysis was performed and models were built for each significant (p 〈 0.01) response variable. Contour plots for each attribute, at each level of roast, were generated and superimposed to determine areas of overlap. Optimum formulations (consumer acceptance rating of ≥ 6.0 for all attributes) for chocolate peanut spread were all combinations of 29-65% peanut, 9-41% chocolate, and 17-36% sugar, adding up to 100%, at a medium roast. Verification of two formulations indicated no difference between predicted and observed values.

Notes: This paper presents the results from a study of consumer reactions to different attributes of red and white wine, with stimuli presented in the form of small, experimentally designed, test concepts (conjoint measurement). The results show that possibly four consumer mind-sets exist, with each mind-set comprising a different set of communication drivers for concept acceptance. Most subjects fit into one of three key categories; “Classics” (who want their wines to be traditional), “Imaginers” (who want to get into the drinking experience through knowing details about their wines) or “Elaborates” (who want their wines to produce many sensations and flavors). A fourth group (No Frills), were interested in simple and safe wines without any detail of flavor or origin. This segment was found in the red wine study, but not in the white wine study.

Notes: This paper describes a method that can be used to investigate consumers’ reported reasons for using a particular product. This method is applied to ratings of degree of agreement with statements about reasons for product use. The method is illustrated using data on self-reported reasons for smoking among adolescents. The approach used is based on a probabilistic model of similarity (Ennis et al. 1988) and provides a display of the density of respondents’ individual motivations concurrent with their perceptions of the statements. Factor analysis and its derived factor scores provide complementary information which is used to understand the interdependence of smoking motivations with the age of respondents and their degree of smoking. The probabilistic similarity model has many applications in studying consumer motivations such as those involved in the consumption of particular food and personal care products.

Notes: The addition of hazelnut paste to dark chocolate formulations altered the sensory profile. The flavors chocolate, burnt, rancid, hazelnut, green and metallic, and the texture attributes hardness, graininess, consistency of melt, viscosity and onset of melt determined by descriptive analysis were significantly (P 〈 0.05) influenced by the addition of up to 10% hazelnut paste. The shelf-life of dark chocolates containing hazelnut exceeded 10 months. The textural attributes of hardness, consistency of melt and onset of melt were highly correlated to instrumental measurements.

Notes: Astringent and bitter sensations are characteristic sensory qualities of black tea. Three different classes of potential astringent reference standards (two concentrations each of alum and tannic acid and three fruit juices) were evaluated in this study. The perceived astringency, bitterness and sourness of each were profiled using computerized time-intensity and compared with the astringent intensity of a standardized brew of black tea. The differences in temporal profiles of potential reference standards across taste attributes were evident and intensity ratings were found to be dependent upon the stimulus and its concentration. Both concentrations of tannic acid were evaluated as the highest in perceived bitterness. For the juices, a strong sour taste was perceived in addition to astringency. It was concluded that the best reference standard for the astringency of black tea is a solution of 0.7 g/L alum as it is low in perceived bitterness and sourness.