Hostname: page-component-76fb5796d-qxdb6 Total loading time: 0 Render date: 2024-04-29T12:46:11.488Z Has data issue: false hasContentIssue false
  • English
  • Français

The Sino-Vietnamese Dispute over the Ethnic Chinese

Published online by Cambridge University Press:  17 February 2009

Pao-min Chang
Get access Rights & Permissions [Opens in a new window]

Extract

As in other South-east Asian countries, the controversy over the ethnic Chinese in Vietnam has its roots deep in the past and in essence centres on the issue of assimilation. However, unlike other countries in the region, Vietnam represents a unique case due to her geographical proximity and cultural affinity to China. Consequently, while ties between the Vietnamese Chinese and their homeland are traditionally closer than in perhaps any other case, over the centuries China has also been more inclined and has found it easier to intervene in Vietnamese affairs. In fact, even after French rule in Vietnam began, Beijing continued to seek to ensure most-favoured-nation treatment for all Chinese in Vietnam through a series of treaties and bilateral agreements, and also responded unfailingly to their pleas for help. According to the agreement signed with the French in 1946, the Chinese Government was even entitled to veto the selection of formal Chinese community leaders in Vietnam, thereby establishing a direct link between China and the Chinese in Vietnam.

Type
Research Article
Information
The China Quarterly , Volume 90 , June 1982 , pp. 195 - 230
Copyright
Copyright © The China Quarterly 1982

Access options

Get access to the full version of this content by using one of the access options below. (Log in options will check for institutional or personal access. Content may require purchase if you do not have access.)

References

1. At least eight major military expeditions overland have been launched against Vietnam since its independence in the 10th century and China's several southward expeditions by sea all had Vietnam as their first target. I-ling, Ch'en, Hua-ch'iao Chih: Yueh-nan (A History of the Chinese in Vietnam) (Taipei: Hua-ch'iao chih wei-yuan hui, 1958), pp. 24–38.Google Scholar Also, Buttinger, Joseph, Vietnam: A Political History (London: André Deutsch, 1968), pp. 19–49.Google Scholar

2. Nhi, Ky Luong, “The Chinese in Vietnam.” Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, University of Michigan, 1963, pp. 118–30Google Scholar; Chang-fu, Li, Chung-kuo chih-min shih (A History of Chinese Immigration) (Taipei: Commercial Press, 1960), pp. 343–44.Google Scholar

3. Ibid. pp. 128–29; Wen-ho, Chang, Yueh-nan hua-ch'iao shih-hua (HistoricalNotes on the Chinese in Vietnam) (Taipei: Li-min ch'u-pan she, 1975), p. 77.Google Scholar

4. Ibid. pp. 57–59.

5. Ibid. p. 61; Ky, op. cit. pp. 184–85.

6. Chang-fu, Li, op. cit. p. 312Google Scholar; Purcell, Victor, The Chinese in South-east Asia (London: Oxford University Press, 1965), p. 182.Google Scholar

7. Ibid. pp. 186–89; Chang-fu, Li, op. cit. pp. 313–14Google Scholar; China Yearbook, 1937 (Shanghai, 1937), p. 307.Google Scholar

8. Chang-fu, Li, op. cit. p. 344.Google Scholar

9. According to recent Vietnamese sources, there were 1·5 million Vietnamese of Chinese descent in 1978 and about 250,000 of them resided in the north. White Paper on Sino- Vietnamese Relations (Hanoi, 1979), p. 38.Google Scholar On the basis of these figures, the Chinese population in Vietnam should have been around 1 to 1·2 million in the 1950s, with about 100,000 to 150,000 in the north.

10. Beijing Review (hereafter BR), 16 06, 1978, p. 17.Google Scholar For a Vietnamese source, see British Broadcasting Corporation, Summary of World Broadcasts, Pt. III, The Far East (hereafter BBC/FE), No. 5896 (21 August 1978), p. A3/2.

11. BR, 16 06 1978, p. 18.Google Scholar

12. Xinhua, New China News Agency (hereafter XHNA), 21 06 1978.Google Scholar

13. Chung-Yueh chiao-o shih-mo (The Sino-Vietnamese Conflict: Origins and Consequences) (Hong Kong: Wen-che ch'u-pan she, 1978), p. 31.Google Scholar

14. China also admitted that Chinese in North Vietnam were well treated before 1975. XHNA, 19 08 1978.Google Scholar

15. Purcell, , op. cit. p. 172.Google Scholar

16. Vietnam News Agency, 27 05 1978Google Scholar, in Monitoring Digest (Singapore) 28–29 05 1978, p. 16.Google Scholar Also, Vietnam Courier (Hanoi), No. 74 (07 1978), p. 3.Google Scholar

17. Yueh-nan hua-ch'iao kuo-cM wen-t'i yen-chiu (A Study of the Nationality Problem of Chinese in Vietnam) (Taipei: Hai-wai ch'u-pan she, 06 1957), pp. 1–2, 23–28.Google Scholar This is a collection of relevant documents on the dispute.

18. See Jan, George, “Nationality and treatment of overseas Chinese in South-east Asia.” Unpublished Ph.D. thesis, New York University, 1960, pp. 90–91Google Scholar; Yueh-nan hua-ch'iao kuo-chi wen-t'i yen-chiu, p. 25.Google Scholar Also, Fall, Bernard B., “Vietnam's Chinese problem,” Far Eastern Survey, Vol. 27, No. 6 (05 1958), pp. 65–72CrossRefGoogle Scholar; Lindhohn, Richard W. (ed.), Vietnam: The First Five Years (Michigan State University Press, 1959), pp. 105–17.Google Scholar

19. Ky, , op. cit. pp. 155–56Google Scholar; Yueh-nan hua-ch'iao kuo-chi wen-t'i yen-chiu, p. 43.Google Scholar

20. Yueh-nan hua-ch'iao kuo-chi wen-t'i yen-chiu, p. 65Google Scholar; Fall, , op. cit. p. 68.Google Scholar

21. Chung-yang jih-pao (Central Daily) (Taipei), 8, 21 05 1957.Google Scholar

22. Renmin Ribao (People's Daily), 21, 22 05 1957.Google Scholar

23. Renmin Ribao, 5 06 1957Google Scholar; also, Far Eastern Economic Review (hereafter FEER), 12 05 1978, p. 9.Google Scholar

24. BR, 16 06 1978, p. 18Google Scholar; also FEER, 16 06 1978, p. 20.Google Scholar

25. Ibid.; BR, 16 06 1978, p. 18.Google Scholar Hanoi has never denied any of this.

26. Chung-yang jih-pao, 1, 4, 5, 7 05 1957.Google Scholar Also, Lindhohn, , op. cit. pp. 113–14.Google Scholar

27. Ibid.; I-ling, Ch'en, op. cit. pp. 127–29;Google ScholarFall, , op. cit. p. 68.Google Scholar

28. FEER, 14 04 1978, pp. 11–12.Google Scholar

29. FEER, 16 06 1978, p. 20.Google Scholar

30. BR, 7 07 1978, p. 29.Google Scholar

31. Ibid.

32. Li Xiannian's Memorandum to Pham Van Dong dated 17 June 1977, in BR, 30 03 1979, p. 21.Google Scholar

33. XHNA, 18 08 1978.Google Scholar But the process appeared to be completed only in late 1976. See Radio Hanoi, 29 May 1978, in Monitoring Digest, 31 05 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

34. FEER, 9 06 1978, p. 11.Google Scholar

35. In February 1977, Beijing officially notified Hanoi of its inability to provide any new aid to Vietnam. BR, 30 03 1979, p. 22.Google Scholar

36. A stream of Vietnamese VIPs, including Pham Van Dong, Vo Nguyen Giap, Truong Chinh, and Le Duan, led separate delegations visiting Moscow in the course of 1977, culminating in the return visit of a Soviet military delegation to Hanoi in October. See Monitoring Digest, 9 March, 5 August, 6 September, 11 October 1977. Moscow supported Vietnam vehemently in her territorial dispute with China as early as 1976, repeatedly warned Hanoi against the untrustworthiness of overseas Chinese communities in 1977, and sided with Hanoi in its conflict with Kampuchea immediately after Beijing's position was made clear in January 1978. BBC/FE, No. 5254 (8 07 1976), pp. A3/1–2Google Scholar; ST, 6 06 1979, p. 2Google Scholar; Simon, Sheldon W., “New Conflict in Indochina,” Problems of Communism, 09–10 1978, p. 32.Google Scholar

37. Turley, William S., “Vietnam Since Reunification,” Problems of Communism, 03–04 1977, pp. 47–48.Google Scholar

38. FEER, 14 04 1978, pp. 11–12Google Scholar; also Chung-yueh chiao-o shih-mo, p. 26.Google Scholar

39. At the Fourth Party Congress, it was planned that four million people would be moved out of urban centres and three million hectares of land would be reclaimed or restored by 1980. Turley, , loc. cit.Google Scholar

40. BR, 11 03 1977, pp. 6–9.Google Scholar For relevant documents, see Issue and Studies, Vol. 13, No. 6 (06 1977), pp. 107–15Google Scholar; No. 8 (August 1977), pp. 77–99, and No. 9 (September 1977), pp. 63–70.

41. Ta Kung Pao (Hong Kong), 21 02 1977.Google Scholar Although the Overseas Chinese Affairs Commission was not restored until early 1978, a new Overseas Chinese Section was set up in the Foreign Ministry by July 1977, as revealed by Huang Hua in his confidential talk to high-level Party cadres on “The Situation of the World” on 30 July 1977. Text reprinted in Chung-kuo ta-lu (Mainland China) (Taipei), No. 127 (15 March 1978), p. 57.

42. FEER, 12 05 1978, pp. 9–10.Google Scholar

43. XHNA, 21 06 1978.Google Scholar

44. BR, 16 06 1978, pp. 14–15Google Scholar; 18 August 1978, p. 28. Accounts by Chinese refugees fleeing Vietnam tend to substantiate these charges. The Straits Times (Singapore) (hereafter ST), 30 May 1978, p. 12.

45. Ibid. Similar accounts made by refugees arriving in Hong Kong may be found in ChingPao (Hong Kong), 07 1978, p. 8.Google Scholar

46. Ibid.; BR, 16 06 1978, p. 15.Google Scholar

47. Ching Pao, 07 1978, p. 8Google Scholar; Chung-Yuehchiao-oshih-mo, p. 30.Google Scholar

48. BR, 18 08 1977, p. 28Google Scholar; also, FEER, 5 05 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

49. BR, 30 03 1979, p. 21.Google Scholar

50. BR, 18 08 1978, pp. 28–29.Google Scholar

51. Monitoring Digest, 31 05 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

52. BR, 16 06 1978, p. 15Google Scholar; FEER, 5 05 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

53. Renmin Ribao, 4 01 1978Google Scholar; also BR, 20 01 1978, pp. 14–16.Google Scholar

54. BR, 10 03 1978, p. 37.Google Scholar

55. Ta Kung Pao, 13 05 1978Google Scholar; Wen Hui Pao (Hong Kong), 2 09 1978.Google Scholar Also Chang, C. Y., “Overseas Chinese in China's policy,” China Quarterly, No. 82 (06–08 1980), p. 282.Google Scholar

56. Monitoring Digest, 1 06 1978, p. 1.Google Scholar

57. ST, 3 05 1978, p. 2Google Scholar; 18 September 1978, p. 1. Also, FEER, 5 05 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

58. FEER, 14 04 1978, p. 11.Google Scholar

59. ST, 4 05 1978, p. 26Google Scholar; FEER, 14 04 1978, p. 12.Google Scholar

60. Chung-Yueh chiao-oshih-mo, p. 16.Google Scholar

61. FEER, 14 04 1978, p. 12.Google Scholar

62. FEER, 5 05 1978, pp. 10–11Google Scholar; 6 May 1978, p. 14. Asiaweek, 28 04 1978, pp. 16–18.Google Scholar

63. ST, 4 05 1978, p. 26Google Scholar; 30 May 1978, p. 12; 27 June 1978, p. 1. Asiaweek, 28 04 1978, pp. 16–18.Google Scholar

64. ST, 22 05 1978, p. 3.Google Scholar

65. For instance, Radio Hanoi in early June reponed that 1,000 Vietnamese in Hanoi had taken over land and properties “abandoned” by ethnic Chinese. ST, 10 06 1978, p.1.Google Scholar

66. ST, 5 05 1978, p. 1.Google Scholar

67. ST, 4 05 1978, p. 26Google Scholar; 6 May 1978, p. 14. Hanoi did not disclose the clashes until September. ST, 18 09 1978, p. 2.Google Scholar

68. BR, 18 08 1978, p. 29.Google Scholar

69. BR, 4 08 1978, p. 19.Google Scholar

70. Calculated on the basis of UNHCR data sheets for 1978.

71. BR, 28 07 1978, pp. 30–31Google Scholar; 18 August 1978, p. 29. Also, ST, 13 07 1979, p. 19.Google Scholar

72. XHNA, 30 04 1978.Google Scholar

73. ST, 6 05 1978, p. 1.Google Scholar

74. BR, 2 06 1978, p. 14.Google Scholar

75. Ibid., pp. 15–16; also BR, 16 06 1978, p. 19.Google Scholar

76. XHNA, 26 05 1978.Google Scholar

77. XHNA, 29 05 1978.Google Scholar

78. XHNA, 1 06 1978.Google Scholar

79. Monitoring Digest, 27 05 1978, pp. 14–15Google Scholar; 28–29 May 1978, p. 16. Vietnam Pictorial (Hanoi), No. 234 (06 1978)Google Scholar, Supplement. Vietnam Courier, No. 74 (07 1978), p. 2.Google Scholar

80. Monitoring Digest, 28–29 05 1978, p. 16Google Scholar; 30 May 1978, p. 20. BBC/FE, No. 5829 (3 06 1978), pp. A3/1–2.Google Scholar

81. BBC/FE, No. 5832 (7 06 1978), p. A3/3.Google Scholar

82. Monitoring Digest, 31 05 1978, p. 31.Google Scholar See also BBC/FE, No. 5827 (1 06 1978), p. A3/1Google Scholar; No. 5837 (7 June 1978), p. A3/3.

83. Monitoring Digest, 28–29 05 1978, p. 17Google Scholar; 30 May 1978, p. 22. Also, BBC/FE, No. 5828 (2 06 1978), pp. A3/1–2.Google Scholar

84. Vietnam Pictorial, No. 234 (06 1978), Supplement.Google Scholar

85. Huang Hua conceded in his talks on 30 July that “in twenty to fifty years, there will be no problem of overseas Chinese any more,” for all overseas Chinese would have been integrated into their host countries and all returned overseas Chinese would have taken root in China. Chung-kuo ta-lu, No. 127 (15 03 1978), p. 57.Google Scholar

86. Xuan Thuy in an interview with Japanese journalists on 9 July maintained that the Chinese Embassy in Hanoi gathered Chinese residents in early 1978 to explain China's new policy toward the overseas Chinese. BBC/FE, No. 5862 (12 07 1978), p. A3/3Google Scholar; see also Vietnam Courier, No. 74 (07 1978), p. 7.Google Scholar

87. This was recognized by both Hanoi and Beijing. BR, 14 07 1978, pp. 26–27Google Scholar; Vietnam Courier, No. 78 (11 1978), p. 10.Google Scholar

88. XHNA, 15 08 and 8 09 1978Google Scholar; ST, 1 08 1978, p. 6Google Scholar; FEER, 22 12 1978, p. 9.Google Scholar

89. BR, 16 06 1978, p. 15.Google Scholar

90. XHNA, 30 05 1978Google Scholar; BBC/FE, No. 5832 (7 06 1978), p. A3/1.Google Scholar

91. XHNA, 30 05 1978.Google Scholar

92. BR, 2 06 1978, pp. 14–15.Google Scholar

93. BBC/FE, No. 5834 (9 06 1978), pp. A3/5–6; No. 5839 (14 June 1978), p. A3/3.Google Scholar

94. BBC/FE, No. 5832 (7 06 1978), p. A3/3.Google Scholar

95. Monitoring Digest, 20 06 1978, p. 22.Google Scholar

96. XHNA, 16 06 1978.Google Scholar

97. BBC/FE, No. 5841 (17 06 1978), pp. A3/1–2.Google Scholar

98. Ibid.

99. The ship “Ghangli” destined for Haiphong can carry 1,300 passengers while the “Minghua” destined for Ho Chi Minh City can carry only 900. Renmin Ribao, 25 06 1978.Google Scholar

100. BBC/FE, No. 5832 (7 06 1978), pp. A3/1–2.Google Scholar

101. BBC/FE, No. 5832 (7 06 1978), P. A3/3Google Scholar; No. 5837 (13 June 1978), p. A3/3; No. 5839 (15 June 1978), p. A3/1; No. 5843 (20 June 1978), p. A3/8.

102. BBC/FE, No. 5849 (27 06 1978)Google Scholar, p. A3/2; No. 5852 (30 June 1978), P. A3/1.

103. XHNA, 22 and 26 06 1978.Google Scholar

104. The departure of thousands of ethnic Chinese fishermen, dockers, and technicians in the north had already caused serious disruptions in various industries by mid-1978. FEER, 4 08 1978, p. 13.Google Scholar

105. XHNA, 29 06 1978.Google Scholar According to a Kyodo News Agency report from Ho Chi Minh City, as many as 250,000 Chinese in Cholon had applied for repatriation. BBC/FE, No. 5855 (4 07 1978), p. A3/7.Google Scholar

106. Vietnam Courier, No. 74 (07 1978), p. 7.Google Scholar

107. XHNA, 25 06 1978.Google Scholar

108. XHNA, 21 06 1978Google Scholar; BR, 30 06 1978, pp. 19–20.Google Scholar

109. BBC/FE, No. 5843 (20 06 1978), p. A3/9Google Scholar; also, XHNA, 21 06 1978.Google Scholar

110. XHNA, 17 06 1978Google Scholar; BBC/FE, No. 5844 (21 06 1978), p. A3/1.Google Scholar

111. BR, 23 06 1978, p. 19Google Scholar; also FEER, 30 06 1978, p. 8.Google Scholar

112. BBC/FE, No. 5843 (20 06 1978), p. A3/6.Google Scholar

113. BBC/FE, No. 5847 (24 06 1978), p. A3/3.Google Scholar

114. Ibid.

115. Ibid.; BBC/FE, No. 5847 (30 June 1978), p. A3/1.

116. XHNA, 28 06 and 2 07 1978.Google Scholar

117. BBC/FE, No. 5851 (29 06 1978), p. A3/5Google Scholar; No. 5852 (30 June 1978), p. A3/1; No. 5859 (8 July 1978), p. A3/2.

118. Japan's Kyodo News Agency reported from Hong Kong in August that many Vietnamese refugees in China had sought to emigrate to Hong Kong and other places due to adjustment problems. BBC/FE, No. 5901 (26 08 1978), p. A3/3Google Scholar. See also ST, 9 10 1978, p. 1.Google Scholar

119. XHNA, 3 07 1978.Google Scholar

120. Vietnam Courier, No. 75 (08 1978), p. 1.Google Scholar

121. XHNA, 11 07 1978.Google Scholar

122. For Vietnamese charges, see BBC/FE, No. 5866 (17 07 1978), pp. A3/6–7Google Scholar; No. 5871 (22 July 1978), pp. A3/4–5. In early August, Beijing began to accuse Hanoi of harassing Chinese going through formalities in Hanoi. XHNA, 1, 12 08 1978.Google Scholar

123. XHNA, 19 07 1978.Google Scholar

124. Simon, , op. cit. pp. 27–28.Google Scholar

125. Up to June, Hanoi had prohibited the departure of any Vietnamese citizens without authorization. ST, 13 July 1978, p. 19. According to informed Vietnamese sources, a directive was issued in August 1978 which instructed local authorities to “hasten the departure of ethnic Chinese from Vietnam” and to encourage the building of refugee boats. ST, 10 07 1979, p. 1.Google Scholar

126. XHNA, 12 08 1978.Google ScholarBR, 15 09 1978, pp. 18–19Google Scholar; 18 August 1978, pp. 25–29; 29 September 1978, p. 22.

127. BBC/FE, No. 5893 (17 08 1978), p. A3/5.Google Scholar

128. BBC/FE, No. 5897 (22 08 1978), p. A3/4.Google Scholar

129. BBC/FE, No. 5905 (1 09 1978), pp. A3/1–3.Google Scholar

130. BBC/FE, No. 5879 (1 08 1978), pp. A3/4–5.Google Scholar

131. Recalling the two passenger ships sent to Vietnam on 28 July, Beijing commented: “China is a victimized party on the issue of persecution and expulsion of Chinese residents in Vietnam. She is naturally anxious to come to an early agreement so that … the victimized Chinese may be relieved of their present misery.” XHNA, 28 July 1978.

132. Hanoi in late July actually declared that the Chinese stranded at the border were “technically” no longer Vietnam's responsibility since they had already been granted exit visas. BBC/FE, No. 5876 (28 07 1978), p. A3/3.Google Scholar Eventually China had to send food across the border to the refugees, which was branded by Hanoi as a trick to entice the Chinese to cross the border. BBC/FE, No. 5897 (22 08 1978), p. A3/2.Google Scholar

133. Calculated on the basis of UNHCR data sheets for 1978. By the end of 1978, no less than 85% of the boat people were ethnic Chinese. FEER, 22 12 1978, pp. 8–12.Google Scholar

134. FEER, 12 05 1978, p. 9 and 22 12 1978, p. 9Google Scholar; ST, 15 11 1978, p. 1Google Scholar and 20 November 1978, p. 2. That Vietnamese authorities were exporting refugees in collaboration with international syndicates was made known when several foreign-registered freighters mysteriously picked up thousands of Vietnamese refugees off the Vietnamese coast in late 1978 and early 1979. ST, 16 11 1978, p. 28Google Scholar; 24 December 1978, p. 2; 22 April 1979, p. 2.

135. Both Vietnam and China claimed that force was applied to the refugees in the process. XHNA, 9, 20 08 1978.Google ScholarBBC/FE, No. 5893 (17 August 1978), p. A3/6; No. 5902 (29 August 1978), pp. A3/1–2.

136. XHNA, 25 08 1978Google Scholar; BBC/FE, No. 5902 (29 August 1978), p. A3/2. Also, FEER, 8 09 1978, p. 10.Google Scholar

137. For instances, XHNA, 13, 20 07, 2, 9, 20, 26 08 1978.Google Scholar

138. For instances, BBC/FE, No. 5881 (3 08 1978), p. A3/6Google Scholar; No. 5883 (5 August 1978), p. A3/3; No. 5897 (22 August 1978), p. A3/2; No. 5900 (25 August 1978), p. A3/3; No. 6902 (29 August 1978), pp. A3/1–2.

139. One incident reportedly resulted from Vietnamese newsmen trying to take pictures of Chinese eating food received from the Chinese side, which provoked a violent reaction from the refugees, thereby leading to the expulsion of over 700 Chinese across the border. XHNA, 9 08 1978.Google Scholar See also note 132 above.

140. XHNA, 5 01 1979.Google Scholar

141. XHNA, 21 08 1978.Google Scholar

142. Such charges were made repeatedly by Beijing. See for instances XHNA, 11 07, 2, 21 08 1978.Google Scholar

143. See Pao-min, Chang, “The Sino-Vietnamese territorial dispute,” Asia-Pacific Community, No. 8 (Spring 1980), pp. 151–52.Google Scholar

144. Reportedly Vietnam started to prepare for a large-scale military offensive to topple Kampuchea after assessing the likelihood of Chinese intervention in April 1978. ST, 19 02 1979, p. 2.Google Scholar

145. Ibid. On the eve of Vietnam's invasion of Kampuchea, Hanoi was reported to be still “supremely confident” that China would not invade Vietnam, and Vietnamese troops stationed along the Sino-Vietnamese border were both small in quantity and irregular in character. FEER, 22 12 1978, p. 17.Google Scholar

146. XHNA, 18 02 1979.Google Scholar

147. Chang Pao-min, loc. cit.

148. The phrase “Teach Vietnam a lesson” was first used by Chinese officials on 8 January 1978. ST, 4 05 1979, p. 16.Google Scholar It was repeated by Deng Xiaoping on 31 January 1979 in the United States, and again on 6 February in Tokyo on his way back to Beijing. New York Times, 1, 7 02 1979.Google Scholar Also, BR, 9 02 1979, p. 3.Google Scholar It was cited again by China after launching the invasion of Vietnam. ST, 28 02 1979, p. 1.Google Scholar

149. XHNA, 18 02 1979.Google Scholar

150. ST, 18 06 1979, p. 3.Google Scholar Vietnamese delegates at the Djarkata Conference in May said that there were at least half-a-million more waiting to leave Vietnam and that the problem lay only in whether other countries were ready to accommodate them, not in Vietnam. New York Times, 13 07 1979.Google Scholar

151. UNHCR data sheets for 1978 and 1979.

152. BR, 27 07 1979, p. 23.Google Scholar The total refugee population in China had reached 250,000.

153. ST, 23 05 1979, p. 1 and 25 May 1979, p. 5.Google Scholar

154. Ibid.; also ST, 6 06 1979, p. 2.Google Scholar The figure is based on the UNHCR data sheet for 1979.

155. New York Times, 13 06 1979.Google Scholar

156. ST, 8 06 1979, p. 36.Google Scholar

157. XHNA, 30 05 1978.Google ScholarST, 31 05 1979, p. 28Google Scholar; 18 June 1979, p. 3; 8 June 1979, p. 1; 29 June 1979, p. 2. New York Times, 13 06 1979.Google Scholar

158. XHNA, 18 04 1979.Google Scholar An estimated 30,000 out of a total of 260,000 refugees accepted by China are ethnic Vietnamese. ST, 10 07 1980, p. 2.Google Scholar

159. BBC/FE, No. 6095 (19 April 1979), p. A3/4; No. 6102 (27 April 1979), pp. A3/11–12.

160. Ibid. p. A3/9; BBC/FE, No. 6161 (6 July 1979), p. A3/2; No. 6155 (30 June 1979), p. A3/2.

161. BBC/FE, No. 6155 (30 06 1979), p. A3/11.Google Scholar

162. The summit of seven developed nations issued a strong statement on 28 June condemning Vietnam, ST, 29 06 1979, p. 36.Google Scholar The conference of ASEAN Foreign Ministers in late June also held Vietnam responsible for the refugee crisis. ST, 2 07 1979, P. 3.Google Scholar

163. BBC/FE, No. 6161 (7 07 1979), p. A3/7Google Scholar; No. 6172 (20 July 1979), p. A3/4.

164. BR, 22 06 1979, pp. 21–22Google Scholar; XHNA, 5, 19 07 1979.Google Scholar

165. BBC/FE, No. 6161 (7 July 1979), p. A3/2; No. 6172 (20 July 1979), p. A3/4.

166. BBC/FE, No. 6161 (7 July 1979), p. A3/2.

167. XHNA, 28 06 1979Google Scholar; BBC/FE, No. 6172 (20 July 1979), p. A3/4.

168. XHNA, 6 03 1980.Google Scholar

169. ST, 10 07 1980, p. 2.Google Scholar

170. UNHCR data sheets for 1979 and 1980.

171. Ibid.

172. It was estimated that at least 50% of all refugees leaving Vietnam by boat perished at sea. ST, 8 06 1979, p. 36.Google Scholar Some informed sources put the casualty rate as high as 70%. New York Times, 13 06 1979.Google Scholar The UNHCR estimated in May 1980 that one out of every two boats that landed in Malaysia had been attacked at sea by pirates. ST, 8 05 1980, p. 2.Google Scholar Also, FEER, 22 12 1978, pp. 13–14.Google Scholar

173. Based on UNHCR estimates. See ST, 13 10 1978, p. 3.Google Scholar