Abstract
The Texas Gulf of Mexico coast is experiencing high (5–11 mm/yr) rates of relative sea level (RSL) rise that are the sum of subsidence and eustatic sea level (ESL) rise. Even higher rates are associated with areas of groundwater pumping from confined aquifers. We investigate the possibility of deep petroleum production as a cause for the high regional rates of subsidence. The northeast Texas coast was chosen for the study because it has a high rate of RSL rise, very limited groundwater production, and a long history of petroleum production. We examine in detail the Big Hill and Fannett fields, for which adequate bottom hole pressure (BHP) and well log data are available. The hypothesis of deep petroleum production is tested in three ways. First, industry BHP tests show many of the fields are depressurized to far below hydrostatic pressures. Second, analysis of BHP data over time in the Big Hill and Fannett fields indicates that some Zones in these fields were below hydrostatic when production commenced. This indicates that depressurization from production in neighboring fields or zones within the same field is not limited to the production zone. Third, three models for subsidence (a general 1-D regional model, an intrareservoir model, and a reservoir bounding layer model), using reasonable hydrogeological parameters, predict subsidence within the inferred range of data. The latter two models use data from the Big Hill and Fannett fields. Additional verification of the hypothesis that deep petroleum production is causing or accelerating regional subsidence will require the collection and analysis of data on the subsurface hydrogeological parameters and detailed measurements of the spatial and temporal distribution of subsidence along the Texas Coast.
This is a preview of subscription content, log in via an institution to check access.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Berg RR and Powers BK (1980) Morphology of turbidite-channel reservoirs, lower Hackberry (Oligocene), southeast Texas. Gulf Coast Assoc Geol Soc Trans 30:41–48
Bernard HA and LeBlanc RJ (1965) Resume of the Quaternary geology of the northwestern Gulf of Mexico province. In: Wright HE and Frey DG (eds), The Quaternary of the United States. Princeton, NJ: Princeton University Press, pp 137–185
Carslaw HS and Jaeger JC (1959) Conduction of heat in solids, 2d ed. London: Oxford Press. 510 pp
Cossey SJ and Jacobs RE (1992) Oligocene Hackberry Formation of southwest Louisiana — sequence stratigraphy, sedimentology, and hydrocarbon potential. Am Assoc Petrol Geol Bull 76:589–606
Dickinson G (1953) Geological aspects of abnormal pressures in Gulf Coast Louisiana. Am Assoc Petrol Geol Bull 37:410–432
Ewing TE and Reed RS (1984) Depositional systems and structural controls of the Hackberry sandstone reservoir systems in south-east Texas. Univ Texas Bur Econ Geol Circ 84-7:48 pp
Gabrysch RK and Bonnet CW (1974) Land-surface subsidence in the Houston-Galveston region, Texas. US Geological Survey Open-File Report 74-123. 23 pp
Gabrysch RK and Bonnet CW (1975) Land-surface subsidence at Seabrook, Texas. US Geological Survey Water Resources Inv. 76-3. 42 pp
Gabrysch RK and Bonnet CW (1976) Land-surface subsidence in the Houston-Galveston region, Texas. Texas Water Development Board Report 188. 19 pp
Galloway WE (1986) Depositional and structural framework of the distal Frio Formation, Texas coastal zone and shelf. Univ Texas Bur Econ Geol Circ 86-8:16 pp
Galloway WE, Hobday DK, and Magara K (1982) Frio Formation of the Texas Gulf Basin—depositional systems, structural framework, and hydrocarbon origin, migration, distribution, and exploration potential. Univ Texas Bur Econ Geol Rep Inv 122:78 pp
Galloway WE, Bebout DG, Fisher WL, Dunlap JB, Jr, Cabrera-Castro R, Lugo-Rivera JE, and Scott TM (1991) Cenozoic. Salvador A (ed), The Gulf of Mexico basin. The Geology of North America. Geological Society of America, Boulder, Colorado: vol J, pp 245–324
Garrett JB (1938) The Hackberry assemblage, an interesting foraminiferal fauna of post-Vicksburg age from deep wells of the Gulf Coast. J Geol 12:309–317
Geertsma J (1973) Land subsidence above compacting oil and gas reservoirs: J Petrol Technol 24:734–744
Germiat SJ and Sharp JM Jr (1990) Assessment of future coastal land loss along the upper Texas Gulf Coast. Bull Assoc Eng Geol 27:263–280
Grimsrud GP, Turner, BL, and Frame PA (1978) Areas of ground water subsidence due to geofluid withdrawal. Lawrence Berkeley Lab Pub 8618
Helm DG (1984) Field-based computational techniques for predicting subsidence due to fluid withdrawal. In: Holzer T (ed), Man-induced land subsidence. Reviews in Engineering Geology, vol 6. Colorado: Geological Society of America, pp 1–22
Hill DW (1993) Land subsidence in the Big Hill and Fannett fields of Jefferson County, Texas: A predictive model. Unpublished MA thesis. Austin, Texas: University of Texas. 134 pp
Holzer TL and Bluntzer RL (1984) Land subsidence near oil and gas fields, Houston, Texas. Ground Water 22:450–459
Jones JL and Larson J (1975) Economic effects of land subsidence due to excessive groundwater withdrawal in the Texas Gulf coast area. College Station, Texas: Texas Water Resources Institute, Texas A&M University. Unpublished report
Kosters EC, Bebout DG, Seni SJ, Garrett CM Jr, Brown LF Jr, Hamlin HS, Dutton SP, Ruppel SJ, Finley RJ, and Tyler N (1989) Atlas of major Texas gas reservoir. Austin, Texas: University of Texas Bureau of Economic Geology. 139 pp
Kreitler CW, Ahkter MS, Donnelly ACA, and Wood WT (1988) Hydrogeology of formations used for deep well injection, Texas Gulf coast. University of Texas Bureau of Economic Geology. Unpublished report
Morton RA (1979) Temporal and spatial variations in shoreline changes and their implications: Examples from the Texas Coast. J Sediment Petrol 49:1101–1112
Morton RA and Paine JG (1991) Beach and vegetation-line changes at Galveston Island, Texas: Erosion, deposition, and recovery from Hurricane Alicia. Univ Texas Bur Econ Geol Geol Circ 85-5:39 pp
Neuzil CE (1986) Groundwater flow in low permeability environments. Water Resour Res 22:1163–1196
Paine JG (1991) Late Quaternary depositional units, sea level, and vertical movement along the central Texas coast. Austin, Texas: University of Texas. Unpublished PhD dissertation. 256 pp
Pratt WE and Johnson DW (1926) Local subsidence in the Goose Creek oil field. J Geol 34:577–590
Ratzlaff KW (1982) Land-surface subsidence in the Texas coastal region. Texas Dep Water Resour Rpt 272:26 pp
Sharp JM Jr (1992) Causes and implications of relative sea-level rise along the Texas Gulf of Mexico coast. In: Simmers I, Villarroya F, Rebollo LF (eds), Selected papers on aquifer overexploitation. Proceedings, 23rd International Congress, International Association of Hydrogeologists, vol 3. pp 131–144
Sharp JM Jr, and Germiat SJ (1990) Risk assessment and the causes of subsidence along the Texas Gulf Coast. In: Fairbridge RW, Paepe R, and Jegersma S (eds), Greenhouse effect, sea level, and drought. Dordrecht: Kluwer Academic Publishers, NATO ASI Series, vol 325. pp. 395–414
Sharp JM Jr, Galloway WE, Land LS, McBride EF, Blanchard PE, Bodner DP, Dutton SP, Farr MR, Gold PB, Jackson TJ, Macpherson GL, and Milliken KL (1988) Diagenetic processes in northwest Gulf of Mexico sediments. In: Chilingarian GV and Wolf KH (eds), Diagensis II Amsterdam: Elsevier. pp 43–113
Sharp JM Jr, Raymond RA, Germiat SJ, and Paine JG (1991) Reevaluation of the causes of subsidence along the Texas Gulf of Mexico coast and some extrapolations of future trends. In: Johnson AI (ed), Land subsidence. International Association of Hydrological Sciences. Publ 200. pp 397–406
Tuma JJ (1983) Handbook of physical calculations. New York: McGraw-Hill. 478 pp
Tyler N (1987) Reexploration of submarine canyon and fan reservoirs at Port Arthur (Hackberry) Field, Jefferson County, Texas. University of Texas, Bureau Economic Geology. Unpublished report
Winker CD (1979) Late Pleistocene fluvial-deltaic depositions of the Texas coastal plain and shelf. Austin, Texas: University of Texas. Unpublished MA thesis. 187 pp
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Sharp, J.M., Hill, D.W. Land subsidence along the northeastern Texas Gulf coast: Effects of deep hydrocarbon production. Geo 25, 181–191 (1995). https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00768547
Received:
Accepted:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/BF00768547