Small-scale lobate hillslope features on Mars: A comparative 3D morphological study with terrestrial solifluction lobes and zebra stripe lobes
Introduction
Solifluction landforms, in the form of downslope oriented lobes, are common in cold-climate environments on Earth. Mars is currently a cold hyper-arid desert planet where contemporary liquid water may be extremely localized and rare (e.g., Ojha et al., 2015). Lobate hillslope features, similar in morphology to terrestrial solifluction lobes have been observed on Mars (Mangold, 2005; Gallagher et al., 2011; Hauber et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2012; Balme et al., 2013; Johnsson et al., 2018). These landforms, termed “Small-Scale Lobes” (SSL), are interpreted to have been formed by solifluction processes due to their morphological similarity to solifluction lobes on Earth (Fig. 1; Gallagher et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2012).
We identified a new terrestrial environment where lobate forms are observed on sloping terrain and could therefore provide an alternative mechanism to solifluction as an explanation for martian SSL. In the Atacama Desert, lobate forms are visible in aerial images on small hills, have been attributed to the action of salts (Beaty, 1983), overland flow (Owen et al., 2013), and seismic shaking (May et al., 2019). This desert is the driest on Earth, and is one of the closest analogues for the current martian climate. One of the main problems facing the solifluction interpretation of SSL on Mars is the fact that extensive thaw is not thought to have been possible in the last 1 Ga (e.g., Kreslavsky et al., 2008). Hence, if a landform similar to SSL can be found in a dry terrestrial environment, it could provide a possible solution to this problem. The lobes are found within zebra stripes in Atacama, whose origin is debated, but is generally accepted to be the result of seismic shaking (May et al., 2019). As seismic shaking from impacts or marsquakes is becoming recognised as a potential element in martian landscape evolution (Roberts et al., 2012; Brown and Roberts, 2019; Kumar et al., 2019), this forms a potentially interesting alternative formation mechanism for martian SSL.
In this study, we performed a comparative morphometric analysis of SSL on Mars, terrestrial periglacial solifluction lobes and the Atacama lobate forms. Previous works relied on plan-view measurements and observations of martian SSL, such as the study of the distribution of small-scale lobes using HiRISE images, or their relationship to other possible ground ice–related landforms such as gullies, polygonally patterned ground, and sorted stripes (Gallagher et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2012; Nyström and Johnsson, 2014; Johnsson et al., 2018). Here, we add topographic context and quantitative 3D analysis of these landforms. These are the first systematic 3D measurements of these features. For this we used data from HiRISE to create DTMs (Digital Terrain Models). For the terrestrial analogues, we used DTMs and orthophotos from Svalbard (Adventdalen), Greenland (Carlsberg Fjord), Sweden (Hödj), the French Alps (Termignon), Iceland (Tindastóll), and the Atacama Desert (Antofagasta). The aim of the study is to use both the new topographic information and comparison with an alternate terrestrial lobate form to assess whether the solifluction interpretation for the martian SSL should be maintained. If the small-scale lobes observed on Mars are indeed the result of solifluction, their existence has important implications for our understanding of recent climate history, the distribution of thaw liquids near the surface, its geomorphic effects and implications for Special Regions for planetary protection (Rummel et al., 2014).
Mars has abundant ground ice from the mid- to high latitudes as shown by GRS (Gamma Ray Spectrometer on Mars Odyssey) (Boynton et al., 2002; Pathare et al., 2018), radar (Mouginot et al., 2010; Bramson et al., 2015; Stuurman et al., 2016) and imaging datasets of fresh craters exposing ice (Byrne et al., 2009; Dundas et al., 2014). In particular the ubiquitous presence of polygonally patterned ground at latitudes higher than ~55° and discontinuously between 30° and 55° is thought to represent the thermal contraction of these ground ice deposits (Mangold et al., 2004; Levy et al., 2009). 98% of martian SSL are found adjacent to, and sometimes superposed on, polygonally patterned ground (Nyström and Johnsson, 2014). If martian SSL are formed by solifluction then they could indicate thaw of this ground ice in the recent past. In support of this hypothesis is the rare observation of ploughing boulders associated with martian SSL (Fig. 2; Johnsson et al., 2018), which on Earth, are intimately associated with solifluction (French, 1976; Ballantyne and Harris, 1994; Ballantyne, 2001). The latitude dependence of SSL orientation also suggests a climatic driver in their formation. SSL are limited to sloping terrain and mainly observed in the northern hemisphere (e.g., Johnsson et al., 2018; Barrett et al., 2018). The southern hemisphere has more steep slopes (Kreslavsky and Head, 2003), so the relative paucity of SSL is not clearly understood, but could be linked to hemispherical differences in surface properties (Johnsson et al., 2018). Mid-latitude (55° to 65°) SSL have a pole-facing preference whereas high-latitude (65° to 80°) ones tend to have an equator-facing preference (Nyström and Johnsson, 2014).
In the arid climate of present-day Mars, the production of liquid water is still a point of debate, and is considered to be slightly more probable in the recent past (e.g., Richardson and Mischna, 2005). This is because Mars has undergone recent climatic shifts due to the variations in its orbital parameters. Contrary to the Earth which is stabilized by the Moon, the obliquity of Mars, currently equal to 25.2°, changes by approximately 20° on a 100 ka cycle (Laskar et al., 2004). According to modelling by Kreslavsky et al. (2008), conditions favouring the formation of an active layer (a thawed layer atop the permafrost) could have last been reached between 10 and 5 Ma.
SSL have been studied by several authors using HiRISE images (Gallagher et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2012; Nyström and Johnsson, 2014; Johnsson et al., 2018). As reported by Nyström and Johnsson (2014), 48% of martian SSL occur in craters that also host gullies. SSL superpose gullies (Gallagher and Balme, 2011) suggesting their age to be equivalent to those of gullies (i.e. the last few Ma; Reiss et al., 2004; Schon et al., 2009; De Haas et al., 2015a). Whether gullies are caused by flowing liquid water/brine or CO2 sublimation triggered flows is a current point of debate (e.g., Conway et al., 2018). Their intimate association with martian SSL suggests that the two landforms are likely to be linked as a landform assemblage, i.e. formed by related processes (Gallagher et al., 2011). Liquid water could be favoured by the presence of perchlorates in the regolith, which were found at the Phoenix site. Perchlorates are molecules which have a eutectic point at 240 K, that maintain water in a liquid state at temperatures below its freezing point (Pestova et al., 2005; Marion et al., 2010). Sublimation of CO2 frost (Sylvest et al., 2016) is not currently favoured to explain martian SSL, because lobes at the foot of the slope are hard to explain as they are lower than the dynamic angle of friction which limits mass wasting processes (Johnsson et al., 2012, Johnsson et al., 2018). However, the distribution of seasonal CO2 matches with the observed latitudinal distribution of martian SSL and a recent study has revealed active rock motion associated with SSL and the seasonal CO2 ice deposits (Dundas et al., 2019).
Finally martian SSL are often associated with landforms that resemble terrestrial sorted patterned ground (Johnsson et al., 2012, Johnsson et al., 2018), which are found in environments with active freeze-thaw cycling. The patterns are outlined by increased concentrations of clasts and can take the form of piles, nets, polygons, circles or stripes depending on the clast concentration and surface slope (Kessler and Werner, 2003). Such patterns have been reported on Mars (Soare et al., 2016; Barrett et al., 2017) and are found in proximity to SSL (Gallagher et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2018).
Mass wasting is defined as the downslope movement of soil/rock induced by gravity. Mass wasting encompasses a number of processes, which can operate together or separately (e.g., Selby, 1982) (Fig. 3a). However, not many of these processes produce lobes. Solifluction processes are known to produce lobes whereas soil creep on its own does not, as shown by field observations (Fig. 3a). Commonly, soil creep is described as the process of downslope soil movement driven by a range of processes (Heimsath and Jungers, 2013) such as moisture and/or temperature fluctuations, or dissolution and recrystallization of salts (Pawlik and Šamonil, 2018). Solifluction, on the other hand, refers to slow downslope movement of water-saturated debris or soils (Gallagher et al., 2011) by cyclic freezing and thawing of water (e.g., Matsuoka, 2001).
Solifluction can be divided into four processes (Matsuoka, 2001). 1) Frost creep is a ratchet-like downslope movement due to a normal frost heave followed by thaw and near vertical settling (Fig. 3b). Frost creep is divided into diurnal and annual frost creep depending on the timescale over which the soil has undergone the freeze-thaw cycle. The timescale of the freezing affects the depth of the movement, for example diurnal frost creep mainly affects the first centimetres of the soil (Matsuoka, 1998) whereas annual frost creep affects a few decimetres (Smith, 1988). 2) Needle ice creep is special kind of diurnal frost creep, occurring when superficial surface debris is lifted perpendicular to the surface by ice needles and then falls again vertically on thawing (Li et al., 2018). 3) Gelifluction occurs on thaw when self-compaction leads to high pore-water pressures resulting in plastic deformation of the soil (Fig. 3b; Harris et al., 2008). 4) When conditions of two-sided freezing occur, there is an additional process called “plug-like” flow in cold permafrost conditions. In this case, the whole active layer is set in motion (Matsuoka, 2001). Morphologically, solifluction lobes can be divided into stone- and turf-banked lobes. However, this morphometric classification does not imply a difference in process forming the lobe. It is likely that vegetation (and animals) strongly influence creep processes and thereby also landform development and morphometry (Eichel et al., 2017). Turf-banked lobes have, for example, a higher sediment thickness and a lower surface velocity than vegetation-free lobes (stone-banked lobes) (Matsuoka, 2001; Harris et al., 2008).
Debris flows are another lobe producing process (Draebing and Eichel, 2018). Debris flows are rapid mass movements of mixtures of sediment (40–50%) and water moving under gravity (Iverson, 1997) and deposit lateral levees as well as terminal lobes of unsorted materials. Draebing and Eichel (2018) compared former debris flow lobes reworked by solifluction with solifluction lobes and only found slight geomorphic differences, with reworked debris flow lobes possessing a more half-moon-like shape while solifluction lobes were more tongue-shaped. However, lobes developed from debris flow lobes have steep catchment areas and a debris flow origin can be deduced from their context (e.g. foot of proximal moraines or alluvial fan; De Haas et al., 2015b; Draebing and Eichel, 2018). We do not examine this particular lobe-forming process in any further detail as we consider similar environmental conditions are required as those that form solifluction lobes sensu stricto.
Section snippets
On Mars
We studied sites containing two types of martian SSL, sorted lobes or clast-banked lobes which have a distinct clast-rich front, and non-sorted lobes where the lobate shape is visible because of the relief (Gallagher et al., 2011; Johnsson et al., 2012). They are thought to be analogous to stone-banked and turf-banked lobes on Earth, respectively, based on their shape (Fig. 4; Benedict, 1976). Based on the dataset presented in Johnsson et al., 2012, Johnsson et al., 2018 and the location of
Approach
Images from the HiRISE camera on the Mars Reconnaissance Orbiter (MRO) with a ~25 cm/pixel resolution were used to derive Digital Terrain Models using the Integrated Software for Imagers and Spectrometers (ISIS3) and Socet Set 5.6.0 following the method outlined in Kirk et al. (2008). Five DTMs with nominal spatial resolution and relative vertical accuracy of 1 m and ~0.5 m respectively were created. Three further publically available DTMs derived using the same procedure were downloaded from //www.uahirise.org/dtm/
Morphometric properties of lobes
We analysed 5148 lobes in total, with 1901 SSL on Mars and 3247 lobes on Earth, of which 2759 are solifluction lobes and 488 are zebra stripe lobes (Table 4). On Mars, we find SSL on slopes ranging from ~10° to ~38°, with a mean and median value of 25° despite all our DTMs containing areas where slopes were below 10°. On Earth, solifluction lobes are found on slopes between ~0° and ~35°, the mean and median values are both equal to 16°. For zebra stripe lobes, the slope where they occur ranges
Martian SSL and terrestrial solifluction lobes
Previous work has concluded that SSL on Mars are likely to be a result of solifluction, because they have similar plan-view morphology, slope-side setting and associated landforms (e.g. ploughing boulders) as solifluction lobes on Earth (Johnsson et al., 2018). Our data reinforce the similarity found in previous work, as we find that martian SSL have similar dimensions, similar topographic position and are found on similar slopes as solifluction lobes. In addition, the fact that SSL on Mars
Conclusions
Digital terrain models of Mars and Earth are used to measure and characterise the morphology of lobate features on both planets. We present here the first extensive three dimensional study of solifluction lobes on Earth, and the first ever 3D data for zebra stripe lobes in the Atacama Desert and SSL on Mars. Our terrestrial data show that it is important to consider that there is a diversity of periglacial environments that host solifluction lobes, where within-hillslope changes of temperature
Acknowledgments
This work was supported by the French Space Agency CNES. The data collection in Termignon, France was made possible by a loan of a Terrestrial Laser Scanner by the UK Natural Environment Research Council Geophysical Equipment Facility loan 1030. The LiDAR and aerial images for Iceland at Tindastóll were made available via the UK NERC Airborne Research Facility and funded by the European Facility for Airborne Research project “EUFAR12_02a” acronym “ICELAND_DEBRISFLOWS”. The Greenland data were
References (88)
- et al.
Clastic patterned ground in Lomonosov crater, Mars: examining fracture controlled formation mechanisms
Icarus
(2017) - et al.
The distribution of putative periglacial landforms on the martian northern plains
Icarus
(2018) Frost creep and gelifluction features: a review
Quat. Res.
(1976)Antiquity of aridity in the Chilean Atacama Desert
Geomorphology
(2006)- et al.
The comparison of topographic long profiles of gullies on Earth to gullies on Mars: a signal of water on Mars
Icarus
(2015) - et al.
Surface morphology of fans in the high-Arctic periglacial environment of Svalbard: controls and processes
Earth-Sci. Rev.
(2015) - et al.
Effects of vegetation type on soil resistance to erosion: relationship between aggregate stability and shear strength
CATENA
(2011) - et al.
Sorted clastic stripes, lobes and associated gullies in high-latitude craters on Mars: landforms indicative of very recent, polycyclic ground-ice thaw and liquid flows
Icarus
(2011) - et al.
An investigation of periglacial slope stability in relation to soil properties based on physical modelling in the geotechnical centrifuge
Geomorphology
(2008) - et al.
Periglacial mass-wasting landforms on Mars suggestive of transient liquid water in the recent past: insights from solifluction lobes on Svalbard
Icarus
(2012)
Slow periglacial mass wasting (solifluction) on Mars
Periods of active permafrost layer formation during the geological history of Mars: implications for circum-polar and mid-latitude surface processes
Planet. Space Sci.
Long term evolution and chaotic diffusion of the insolation quantities of Mars
Icarus
High latitude patterned grounds on Mars: classification, distribution and climatic control
Icarus
Modeling aqueous perchlorate chemistries with applications to Mars
Icarus
Seismic origin of the Atacama Desert boulder fields
Geomorphology
Solifluction rates, processes and landforms: a global review
Earth-Sci. Rev.
Zebra stripes in the Atacama Desert revisited – granular fingering as a mechanism for zebra stripe formation?
Geomorphology
The 3–5 MHz global reflectivity map of Mars by MARSIS/Mars Express: implications for the current inventory of subsurface H2O
Icarus
Zebra stripes in the Atacama Desert: fossil evidence of overland flow
Geomorphology
Driven by excess? Climatic implications of new global mapping of near-surface water-equivalent hydrogen on Mars
Icarus
Soil creep: the driving factors, evidence and significance for biogeomorphic and pedogenic domains and systems – a critical literature review
Earth-Sci. Rev.
Variability of the martian seasonal CO2 cap extent over eight Mars Years
Icarus
Initiation and growth of martian ice lenses
Icarus
Sorted (clastic) polygons in the Argyre region, Mars, and possible evidence of pre-and post-glacial periglaciation in the Late Amazonian Epoch
Icarus
Mass wasting features on the Moon–how active is the lunar surface?
Earth Planet. Sci. Lett.
Avalanche slope angles in low-gravity environments from active Martian sand dunes
Geophys. Res. Lett.
Measurement and theory of ploughing boulder movement
Permafr. Periglac. Process.
The Periglaciation of Great Britain
Morphological evidence for geologically young thaw of ice on Mars: a review of recent studies using high-resolution imaging data
Prog. Phys. Geogr.
Tiger-striping; a curious form of surficial patterning in the Atacama Desert, N. Chile
Mineralogic and compositional properties of Martian soil and dust: results from Mars Pathfinder
J. Geophys. Res. Planets
Distribution of hydrogen in the near surface of Mars: evidence for subsurface ice deposits
science
Widespread excess ice in Arcadia Planitia, Mars
Geophys. Res. Lett.
Possible evidence for variation in magnitude for marsquakes from fallen boulder populations, Grjota Valles, Mars
J. Geophys. Res. Planets
A new formation process for patterned ground, Atacama Desert, Chile
Distribution of mid-latitude ground ice on Mars from new impact craters
science
Atmospheric origins of perchlorate on Mars and in the Atacama
J. Geophys. Res. Planets
Martian gullies: a comprehensive review of observations, mechanisms and insights from Earth analogues
Geol. Soc. Lond. Spec. Publ.
Earth-like aqueous debris-flow activity on Mars at high orbital obliquity in the last million years
Nat. Commun.
Divergence, convergence, and path dependency of paraglacial adjustment of alpine lateral moraine slopes
Land Degrad. Dev.
HiRISE observations of new impact craters exposing Martian ground ice
J. Geophys. Res. Planets
Active boulder movement at high Martian latitudes
Geophys. Res. Lett.
Solifluction meets vegetation: the role of biogeomorphic feedbacks for turf-banked solifluction lobe development
Earth Surf. Process. Landf.
Cited by (5)
A billion or more years of possible periglacial/glacial cycling in Protonilus Mensae, Mars
2022, IcarusCitation Excerpt :At the mid- to relatively high-latitudes of Mars' northern plains, surface textures, landscape features, landforms and spatially-continuous landform assemblages reminiscent of current and/or relict periglacial terrain on Earth have been reported widely (e.g. Costard and Kargel, 1995; Mustard et al., 2001; Seibert and Kargel, 2001; Soare et al., 2008, 2014; Soare et al., 2017, Soare et al., 2018; Balme et al., 2009; Levy et al., 2009a, 2009b, 2010; Ulrich et al., 2010; Gallagher et al., 2011; Hauber et al., 2011; Séjourné et al., 2011, 2012; Barrett et al., 2017, 2018; Johnsson et al., 2018; Gastineau et al., 2020).
The role of liquid water in recent surface processes on Mars
2021, Mars Geological Enigmas: From the Late Noachian Epoch to the Present DayPlanetary geomorphology
2022, Geological Society MemoirArctic soil patterns analogous to fluid instabilities
2021, Proceedings of the National Academy of Sciences of the United States of America