Abstract
Greening flood protection (GFP) is increasingly recognized as an adaptive and flexible approach to water management that is well suited to addressing uncertain futures associated with climate change. In the last decade, GFP knowledge and policies have developed rapidly, but implementation has been less successful and has run into numerous barriers. In this paper, we address the challenge of realizing green flood protection goals by specifically considering knowledge in the decision-making of a Dutch flood protection project in Lake Markermeer. In this project, an ecological knowledge arrangement and a traditional flood protection knowledge arrangement are compared and their interactions analysed. The analysis provides insight into the specific difficulties of implementing GFP measures and identifies ways to realize GFP goals. The primary challenge is twofold: First, a self-reinforcing cycle of knowledge production and decision-making in the flood protection domain inhibits the introduction of innovative and multifunctional approaches such as GFP; second, the distribution of power is severely unbalanced in terms of ecological enhancement and flood protection, favouring the latter. Implementation of GFP requires structural change and the integration of ecological and flood protection knowledge and policy. Potentially rewarding routes towards this integration are the exploration of shared interests in GFP and the creation of mutual dependency between knowledge arrangements. The case study and the insights it provides show that GFP is far from mainstream practice and that implementation requires serious effort and courage to break with historical practices.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Abel N, Gorddard R, Harman B, Leitch A, Langridge J, Ryan A, Heyenga S (2011) Sea level rise, coastal development and planned retreat: analytical framework, governance principles and an Australian case study. Environ Sci Policy 14(3):279–288. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2010.12.002
Aerts JCJH, Botzen WJW (2013) Climate adaptation cost for flood risk management in the Netherlands. In: Hill D, Bowman MJ, Khinda JS (eds) Storm surge barriers to protect New York city. American Society of Civil Engineers, Reston, Virginia, pp 99–113. doi:10.1061/9780784412527.007
Aerts JCJH, Sprong TA, Bannink B (2008) Aandacht voor Veiligheid. http://www.deltacommissie.com/doc/Aandacht%20voor%20veiligheid%20.pdf
Ayanu Y, Jentsch A, Müller-Mahn D, Rettberg S, Romankiewicz C, Koellner T (2015) Ecosystem engineer unleashed: Prosopis juliflora threatening ecosystem services? Reg Environ Change 15(1):155–167. doi:10.1007/s10113-014-0616-x
Barbier EB, Koch EW, Silliman BR, Hacker SD, Wolanski E, Primavera J, Granek EF, Polasky S, Aswani S, Cramer LA, Stoms DM, Kennedy CJ, Bael D, Kappel CV, Perillo GME, Reed DJ (2008) Coastal ecosystem-based management with nonlinear ecological functions and values. Science 319(5861):321–323. doi:10.1126/science.1150349
Bergen SD, Bolton SM, Fridley JL (2001) Design principles for ecological engineering. Ecol Eng 18(2):201–210. doi:10.1016/S0925-8574(01)00078-7
Berkhout F (2002) Technological regimes, path dependency and the environment. Glob Environ Change 12(1):1–4. doi:10.1016/S0959-3780(01)00025-5
Borsje BW, van Wesenbeeck BK, Dekker F, Paalvast P, Bouma TJ, van Katwijk MM, de Vries MB (2011) How ecological engineering can serve in coastal protection. Ecol Eng 37(2):113–122. doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2010.11.027
Brugnach M, Ingram H (2012) Ambiguity: the challenge of knowing and deciding together. Environ Sci Policy 15(1):60–71. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2011.10.005
Cash DW, Clark WC, Alcock F, Dickson NM, Eckley N, Guston DH, Jäger J, Mitchell RB (2003) Knowledge systems for sustainable development. Proc Natl Acad Sci USA 100(14):8086–8091. doi:10.1073/pnas.1231332100
Cheong SM, Silliman B, Wong PP, Van Wesenbeeck B, Kim CK, Guannel G (2013) Coastal adaptation with ecological engineering. Nat Clim Change 3(9):787–791. doi:10.1038/nclimate1854
Coen LD, Brumbaugh RD, Bushek D, Grizzle R, Luckenbach MW, Posey MH, Powers SP, Tolley SG (2007) Ecosystem services related to oyster restoration. Mar Ecol Prog Ser 341:303–307
Deelstra Y, Nooteboom SG, Kohlmann HR, Van Den Berg J, Innanen S (2003) Using knowledge for decision-making purposes in the context of large projects in The Netherlands. Environ Impact Assess Rev 23(5):517–541. doi:10.1016/S0195-9255(03)00070-2
Deltares (2012) Verslag van de building with nature workshop: Oeverdijk als ecologisch alternatief voor dijkversterking? 6 Dec 2011, op Marken
Doremus H (2009) CALFED and the quest for optimal institutional fragmentation. Environ Sci Policy 12(6):729–732. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2009.06.004
Edelenbos J, Van Buuren MW, Van Schie N (2011) Co-producing knowledge: joint knowledge production between experts, bureaucrats and stakeholders in Dutch water management projects. Environ Sci Policy 14(6):675–684. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2011.04.004
Eshuis J, Stuiver M (2005) Learning in context through conflict and alignment: farmers and scientists in search of sustainable agriculture. Agric Hum Values 22(2):137–148. doi:10.1007/s10460-004-8274-0
Feldman DL, Ingram HM (2009) Making science useful to decision makers: climate forecasts, water management, and knowledge networks. Weather Clim Soc 1(1):9–21. doi:10.1175/2009WCAS1007.1
Feldman MS, Khademian AM, Ingram H, Schneider AL (2006) Ways of knowing and inclusive management practices. Public Adm Rev 66(SUPPL. 1):89–99. doi:10.1111/j.1540-6210.2006.00669.x
Gedan KB, Kirwan ML, Wolanski E, Barbier EB, Silliman BR (2011) The present and future role of coastal wetland vegetation in protecting shorelines: answering recent challenges to the paradigm. Clim Change 106(1):7–29. doi:10.1007/s10584-010-0003-7
Gersonius B, Ashley R, Pathirana A, Zevenbergen C (2013) Climate change uncertainty: building flexibility into water and flood risk infrastructure. Clim Change 116(2):411–423. doi:10.1007/s10584-012-0494-5
Giebels D, Van Buuren MW, Edelenbos J (2013) Ecosystem-based management in the Wadden Sea: principles for the governance of knowledge. J Sea Res 82:176–187. doi:10.1016/j.seares.2012.11.002
Haarman FG, Capel A, De Kant M, Akkerman GJ, Noordhuis R, Wichman BGHM (2010) Dijkversterking Markermeerkust Hoorn-Amsterdam. De oeverdijk als extra alternatief? Royal Haskoning
Hale LZ, Meliane I, Davidson S, Sandwith T, Beck M, Hoekstra J, Spalding M, Murawski S, Cyr N, Osgood K, Hatziolos M, Van Eijk P, Davidson N, Eichbaum W, Dreus C, Obura D, Tamelander J, Herr D, McClennen C, Marshall P (2009) Ecosystem-based adaptation in marine and coastal ecosystems. Renew Resour J 25(4):21–28
Hegger D, Van Zeijl-Rozema A, Dieperink C (2012) Toward design principles for joint knowledge production projects: lessons from the deepest polder of The Netherlands. Reg Environ Change. doi:10.1007/s10113-012-0382-6
Hommes S (2008) Conquering Complexity, Dealing with uncertainty and ambiguity in watermanagement, University of Twente, The Netherlands, Ph.D. thesis.
Hommes S, Vinke-de Kruijf J, Otter HS, Bouma G (2009) Knowledge and perceptions in participatory policy processes: lessons from the delta-region in the Netherlands. Water Resour Manag 23(8):1641–1663. doi:10.1007/s11269-008-9345-6
Huitema D, Mostert E, Egas W, Moellenkamp S, Pahl-Wostl C, Yalcin R (2009) Adaptive water governance: assessing the institutional prescriptions of adaptive (co-)management from a governance perspective and defining a research agenda. Ecol Soc 14(1):26
Hunt J, Shackley S (1999) Reconceiving science and policy: academic, fiducial and bureaucratic knowledge. Minerva 37(2):141–164. doi:10.1023/A:1004696104081
Imperial MT (2005) Using collaboration as a governance strategy: lessons from six watershed management programs. Adm Soc 37(3):281–320. doi:10.1177/0095399705276111
Janssen SKH, Mol APJ, Van Tatenhove JPM, Otter HS (2014a) The role of knowledge in greening flood protection. Lessons from the Dutch case study future Afsluitdijk. Ocean Coast Manag 95:219–232. doi:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2014.04.015
Janssen SKH, van Tatenhove JPM, Otter HS, Mol APJ (2014b) Greening flood protection—an interactive knowledge arrangement perspective. J Environ Policy Plan. doi:10.1080/1523908X.2014.947921
Kabat P, Van Vierssen W, Veraart J, Vellinga P, Aerts J (2005) Climate proofing the Netherlands. Nature 438(7066):283–284. doi:10.1038/438283a
Katsanevakis S, Stelzenmüller V, South A, Sørensen TK, Jones PJS, Kerr S, Badalamenti F, Anagnostou C, Breen P, Chust G, D’Anna G, Duijn M, Filatova T, Fiorentino F, Hulsman H, Johnson K, Karageorgis AP, Kröncke I, Mirto S, Pipitone C, Portelli S, Qiu W, Reiss H, Sakellariou D, Salomidi M, van Hoof L, Vassilopoulou V, Vega Fernández T, Vöge S, Weber A, Zenetos A, Hofstede RT (2011) Ecosystem-based marine spatial management: review of concepts, policies, tools, and critical issues. Ocean Coast Manag 54(11):807–820. doi:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2011.09.002
Korbee D, Van Tatenhove JPM (2013) Environmental governance for marine infrastructure: enabling and constraining conditions for ecodynamic development and design in marine infrastructural projects. J Environ Plan Policy Manag 15(4):533–550. doi:10.1080/1523908X.2013.807211
Lammens E, Van Luijn F, Wessels Y, Bouwhuis H, Noordhuis R, Portielje R, Van Der Molen D (2008) Towards ecological goals for the heavily modified lakes in the IJsselmeer area, the Netherlands. Hydrobiologia 599(1):239–247. doi:10.1007/s10750-007-9202-2
Lejano RP, Ingram H (2009) Collaborative networks and new ways of knowing. Environ Sci Policy 12(6):653–662. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2008.09.005
Martin TG, Watson JEM (2016) Intact ecosystems provide best defence against climate change. Nat Clim Change 6(2):122–124. doi:10.1038/nclimate2918
McNie EC (2007) Reconciling the supply of scientific information with user demands: an analysis of the problem and review of the literature. Environ Sci Policy 10(1):17–38. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2006.10.004
Meijerink S, Huitema D (2010) Policy entrepreneurs and change strategies: Lessons from sixteen case studies of water transitions around the globe. Ecol Soc 15(2)
Ministerie van V&W (2009) Nationaal Waterplan. https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/rapporten/2009/12/01/nationaal-waterplan-2009-2015
Mitsch WJ, Jørgensen SE (2003) Ecological engineering: a field whose time has come. Ecol Eng 20(5):363–377. doi:10.1016/j.ecoleng.2003.05.001
Mulder JPM, Hommes S, Horstman EM (2011) Implementation of coastal erosion management in the Netherlands. Ocean Coast Manag 54(12):888–897. doi:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2011.06.009
Muñoz-Erickson TA (2013) Co-production of knowledge-action systems in urban sustainable governance: the KASA approach. Environ Sci Policy 37:182–191. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2013.09.014
Nieuwaal M, Sarink H, Van Hemert H, Eikelenboom JH (2010) Memo Haalbaarheidsstudie Voorlandkeringen Markermeerdijken
Noordhuis R, Wichman BGHM (2012) Ecologische uitwerking van het oeverdijkconcept. Op basis van ecologische uitgangspunten en grove inschatting waterkeringsveiligheid
Petts J, Brooks C (2006) Expert conceptualisations of the role of lay knowledge in environmental decisionmaking: challenges for deliberative democracy. Environ Plan A 38(6):1045–1059. doi:10.1068/a37373
PIANC (2011) PIANC Position paper ‘Working with Nature’ Oct 2008; revised January 2011. http://www.pianc.org/downloads/envicom/WwN%20Final%20position%20paper%20January%202011.pdf
Porzecanski I, Saunders LV, Brown MT (2012) Adaptive management fitness of watersheds. Ecol Soc 17(3):29
Rinaudo JD, Garin P (2005) The benefits of combining lay and expert input for water-management planning at the watershed level. Water Policy 7(3):279–293
Runhaar H, Mees H, Wardekker A, van der Sluijs J, Driessen PPJ (2012) Adaptation to climate change-related risks in Dutch urban areas: stimuli and barriers. Reg Environ Change 12(4):777–790. doi:10.1007/s10113-012-0292-7
Seijger C, Van Tatenhove JPM, Dewulf G, Otter HS (2014) Responding to coastal problems: interactive knowledge development in a US nature restoration project. Ocean Coast Manag 89:29–38. doi:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2013.12.011
Smale AJ, De Vroeg H, Capel A (2012) Meerwaarde luwtestructuur voor de oeverdijk. Deltares
Spalding MD, Ruffo S, Lacambra C, Meliane I, Hale LZ, Shepard CC, Beck MW (2013) The role of ecosystems in coastal protection: adapting to climate change and coastal hazards. Ocean Coast Manag 90:50–57. doi:10.1016/j.ocecoaman.2013.09.007
Spencer KL, Harvey GL (2012) Understanding system disturbance and ecosystem services in restored saltmarshes: integrating physical and biogeochemical processes. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 106:23–32
Steetzel HJ (2012) Definitiestudie oeverdijk ontwikkeling M.E.R.-rijp alternatief hoofdrapport. Arcadis
Stuurgroep_TMIJ (2008) Investeren in Markermeer en IJmeer. Ontwikkelingsperspectief en actieplan
Sullivan W, Rees J (2008) Clean language. Revealing metaphors and opening minds. Crown House Publishing Limited, Carmarthen
Temmerman S, Meire P, Bouma TJ, Herman PMJ, Ysebaert T, De Vriend HJ (2013) Ecosystem-based coastal defence in the face of global change. Nature 504(7478):79–83. doi:10.1038/nature12859
Turnhout E, Hisschemöller M, Eijsackers H (2007) Ecological indicators: between the two fires of science and policy. Ecol Ind 7(2):215–228. doi:10.1016/j.ecolind.2005.12.003
Van Broekhoven S, Vernay AL (2011) Integrating functions for a sustainable urban system. Crossing boundaries between domains. Paper presented at the IGS-SENSE conference, Enschede, The Netherlands, 19–21 Oct
Van Buuren MW (2009) Knowledge for governance, governance of knowledge: inclusive knowledge management in collaborative governance processes. Int Public Manag J 12(2):208–235. doi:10.1080/10967490902868523
Van Buuren MW, Edelenbos J (2004) Why is joint knowledge production such a problem? Sci Public Policy 31(4):289–299. doi:10.3152/147154304781779967
Van Buuren MW, De Bruin E, Zweegman G-J, Becker L, Raadgever T (2010) Strategieën voor integrale kustontwikkeling in een versnipperd institutioneel systeem. APPM, Zoetermeer
Van de Riet AWT (2003) Policy analysis in multi-actor policy settings: navigating between negotiated nonsense and superfluous knowledge. Eburon Publishers, Delft
Van den Hoek RE, Brugnach M, Hoekstra AY (2012) Shifting to ecological engineering in flood management: introducing new uncertainties in the development of a Building with Nature pilot project. Environ Sci Policy 22:85–99. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2012.05.003
Van den Hoek RE, Brugnach M, Mulder JPM, Hoekstra AY (2013) Analysing the cascades of uncertainty in flood defence projects: how “not knowing enough” is related to “knowing differently”. Glob Environ Change. doi:10.1016/j.gloenvcha.2013.11.008
Van der Brugge R, Rotmans J, Loorbach D (2005) The transition in Dutch water management. Reg Environ Change 5(4):164–176. doi:10.1007/s10113-004-0086-7
Van der Linde A, Melissen C, M. T, M. M, Schultz S (2012) Dijkversterking Hoorn-Amsterdam Adviesnota voorkeursalternatief. Royal HaskoningDHV/Arcadis
Van der Molen F, van der Windt HJ, Swart JAA (2016) The interplay between knowledge and governance: insights from the governance of recreational boating in the Dutch Wadden Sea area, 1981–2014. Environ Sci Policy. doi:10.1016/j.envsci.2015.02.012
Van Helsdingen A, Lawley J (2012) Zuiver belevingsonderzoek: het vermijden van onbedoelde beïnvloeding in kwalitatief onderzoek. KWALON 17(3):43–50
Van Koningsveld M, Mulder JPM (2004) Sustainable coastal policy developments in the Netherlands. A systematic approach revealed. J Coast Res 20(2):375–385. doi:10.2112/1551-5036(2004)020[0375:SCPDIT]2.0.CO;2
Van Koningsveld M, Stive MJF, Mulder JPM, De Vriend HJ, Ruessink BG, Dunsbergen DW (2003) Usefulness and effectiveness of coastal research: a matter of perception? J Coast Res 19(2):441–461
Van Meurs GAM (2008) Dijkversterking Edam-Amsterdam. Quick-Scan dubbeldoelstelling Veiligheid en verbeteren Ecologie. Deltares
Van Meurs GAM, Mens AMJ, Altamirano MA (2010) Quick scan ecologische meerwaarde alternatief oeverdijk. Dijkversterking op het traject Hoorn-Amsterdam. Deltares
Van Slobbe E, De Vriend HJ, Aarninkhof S, Lulofs K, De Vries M, Dircke P (2013) Building with nature: in search of resilient storm surge protection strategies. Nat Hazards 65(1):947–966. doi:10.1007/s11069-012-0342-y
Van Tatenhove JPM, Arts B, Leroy P (eds) (2000) Political modernisation and the environment. The renewal of environmental policy arrangements. Kluwer, Dordrecht
Van Wesenbeeck BK, Mulder JPM, Marchand M, Reed DJ, de Vries MB, de Vriend HJ, Herman PMJ (2014) Damming deltas: a practice of the past? Towards nature-based flood defenses. Estuar Coast Shelf Sci 140:1–6. doi:10.1016/j.ecss.2013.12.031
Van Winden A, Maka C (2012) Oeverdijken: kans voor veiligheid en natuur
Vikolainen V, Bressers H, Lulofs K (2012) Implementing eu natura 2000 at the project level: lessons from the Veluwe border lakes in the Netherlands. Public Adm 90(4):1016–1031. doi:10.1111/j.1467-9299.2011.01971.x
Walker W (2000) Entrapment in large technology systems: institutional commitment and power relations. Res Policy 29(7–8):833–846. doi:10.1016/S0048-7333(00)00108-6
Walker B, Gunderson L, Kinzig A, Folke C, Carpenter S, Schultz L (2006) A handful of heuristics and some propositions for understanding resilience in social-ecological systems. Ecol Soc 11(1):13
Wichman BGHM, Noordhuis R, De Vries MB, Van de Wal M, De Rijk S (2011) Synergie veiligheid en ecologie. Verkenning oeverdijk met TBES maatregelen. Deltares
Wiering M, Arts BJM (2006) Discursive shifts in Dutch river management: ‘Deep’ institutional change or adaptation strategy? Hydrobiologia 565(1 SPEC. ISS.):327–338. doi:10.1007/1-4020-5367-3_22
Woltjer J, Al N (2007) Integrating water management and spatial planning: strategies based on the Dutch experience. J Am Plan Assoc 73(2):211–222. doi:10.1080/01944360708976154
Wondolleck JM, Yaffee SL (2000) Making collaboration work: lessons from innovation in natural resource management. Island Press, Washington
Acknowledgments
We thank the employees of HHNK for their support in searching for data. We are grateful to the interview respondents for sharing information and time. This paper has benefited from discussions with Bas Borsje, Bertien Broekhans and Trudes Heems, as well as participants of the panel ‘Making sense and managing sensitivities of designing and developing multipurpose technological artefacts’ at IPA 2013 in Vienna. Arjen Francke performed interviews for the case study, of which we have taken full advantage. We thank the anonymous reviewers for their helpful comments. This research was financially supported by the Building with Nature program (www.ecoshape.nl).
Author information
Authors and Affiliations
Corresponding author
Additional information
Editor: Sarah Gergel.
Electronic supplementary material
Below is the link to the electronic supplementary material.
Rights and permissions
About this article
Cite this article
Janssen, S.K.H., van Tatenhove, J.P.M., Mol, A.P.J. et al. Greening flood protection through knowledge processes: lessons from the Markermeer dikes project in the Netherlands. Reg Environ Change 17, 551–563 (2017). https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-016-1040-1
Received:
Accepted:
Published:
Issue Date:
DOI: https://doi.org/10.1007/s10113-016-1040-1