Abstract
This paper demonstrates a parametric test of specification that can be used in validating econometric models employing pooled time series and cross-section data with fixed effects. This Lagrange multiplier test allows for the simultaneous testing of proper model functional form and the presence of nonspherical disturbances, using a combination of the Box-Cox transformation, the double-length regression of Davidson and MacKinnon, and the Bonferroni inducedt-test. Testing procedures are demonstrated using a model of long distance telephone demand in the United States. The illustrative model used is representative of models filed as direct testimony by telephone companies in administrative law proceedings, which usually require rigorous model validation and defenses of model results in a formal hearing room setting. The tests presented in this paper are useful to a wide variety of researchers who use pooled econometric models with fixed effects in their work.
Similar content being viewed by others
References
Acton JP and Vogelsang I (1990) Telephone Demand Over the Atlantic: Evidence from Country-Pair Data. RAND Monograph R-3715-NSF/MF, (Santa Monica: The RAND Corporation)
Appelbe TW, Dineen CR, Solvason DL and Hsiao C. Econometric Modelling of Canadian Long Distance Calling: A Comparison of Aggregate Time Series and Point-to-Point Panel Data Approaches.Empirical Economics, forthcoming
Appelbe TW, Snihur NA, Dineen C, Farnes D and Giordano R (1989) Point-to-Point Demand Modelling: An Application to Canada-Canada and Canada-United States Long Distance Calling.Information Economics and Policy 3:311–331
Bailey JR (1977) Tables of the Bonferronit Statistics.Journal of the American Statistical Society 72:469–478
Bera A and Jarque M (1982) Model Specification Tests: A Simultaneous Approach.Journal of Econometrics 20:59–82
Box GEP and Cox DR (1964) An Analysis of Transformations.Journal of the Royal Statistical Society, Series B 26:211–243
Davidson R and MacKinnon JG (1984) Model Specification Tests Based on Artificial Linear Regressions.International Economic Review 25:485–502
Davidson R and MacKinnon JG (1985) Testing Linear and Loglinear Regressions Against Box-Cox Alternatives.Canadian Journal of Economics 18:499–517
Griffin JM (1982) The Welfare Implications of Externalities and Price Elasticities for Telecommunications Pricing.Review of Economics and Statistics 64:59–66
Larson AC (1987) Using the Box-Cox Transformation with Pooled Time Series and Cross-Section Data. Paper presented at the Australasian Meeting of the Econometric Society, Christchurch, New Zealand
Larson AC, Lehman DE and Weisman DL (1990) A General Theory of Point-to-Point Long Distance Demand. In A. de Fontenay, M. Shugard and D. Sibley, (Eds),Telecommunications Demand Modeling: An Integrated View, (North-Holland, Amsterdam), 299–318
Pacey PL (1983) Long Distance Demand: A Point-to-Point Model.Southern Economic Journal 50:1094–1107
Savin NE Multiple Hypothesis Testing. In Z. Griliches and M.D. Intriligator (Eds)Handbook of Econometrics, Volume II, (Elsevier: Amsterdam), 827–879
Taylor LD (1980)Telecommunications Demand: A Survey and Critique, (Ballinger: Cambridge, MA)
Watters JS.Inquiry of the General Counsel into the Reasonableness of the Rates and Services of Southwestern Bell Telephone Company, State of Texas, Docket No. 8585, rebuttal testimony filed Nov. 27, 1989 on behalf of Southwestern Bell Telephone Company