Is the fixation of observable mutations distributed randomly among the three nucleotide positions of the codon?

Summary

The distribution among the three nucleotide positions of the codons of 642 mutations fixed during the descent of 49 sequences of cytochromec was examined. This was compared to the distribution expected if the number of ways of getting a selectively acceptable amino acid alternative from a single nucleotide replacement at each coding position were random,i.e. proportional to the total number of ways of changing the encoded amino acid by a single nucleotide replacement at each coding position. It was found that the observed distribution was significantly different from random, there being 40% more mutations in the first coding position than in the second whereas one would have expected 10% more in the second than in the first. The probability of the result occurring by chance is < 10⁻⁶.

The same test was made on the distribution of 347 mutations fixed in the descent of 19 sequences of alpha hemoglobin and 286 mutations fixed in the descent of 16 beta and 4 delta hemoglobins. The result for the alpha hemoglobins was a similar non-randomness but the probability of its occurring by chance rose to 0.005. The result for the beta-delta hemoglobins was in the same direction but was not significant (p = 0.3). The degree of non-randomness among the three genes in the distribution of fixations over the three nucleotide positions of their codons appears to be correlated (negatively) with their rates of evolution, the plasticity required of the molecule to adapt to new environments, and the recency of exploitation of opportunities for change in functional specificity provided by such processes as gene duplication.