Publication Date:
2016-03-23
Description:
The quest to find new statistical symmetries in the theory of turbulence is an ongoing research endeavor which is still in its beginning and exploratory stage. In our comment we show that the recently performed study of Wacławczyk and Oberlack [J. Math. Phys. 54 , 072901 (2013)] failed to present such new statistical symmetries. Despite their existence within a functional Fourier space of the statistical Burgers equation, they all can be reduced to the classical and well-known symmetries of the underlying deterministic Burgers equation itself, except for one symmetry, but which, as we will demonstrate, is only a mathematical artefact without any physical meaning. Moreover, we show that the proposed connection between the translation invariance of the multi-point moments and a symmetry transformation associated to a certain invariant solution of the inviscid functional Burgers equation is invalid. In general, their study constructs and discusses new particular solutions of the functional Burgers equation without referring them to the well-established general solution. Finally, we also see a shortcoming in the presented methodology as being too restricted to construct a complete set of Lie point symmetries for functional equations. In particular, for the considered Burgers equation essential symmetries are not captured.
Print ISSN:
0022-2488
Electronic ISSN:
1089-7658
Topics:
Mathematics
,
Physics
Permalink
