Publication Date:
2023-08-09
Description:
Traditional "physically-based" hydrological models consider soil to be key in hydrology. According to these models, soil properties determine water movement in both saturated and unsaturated zones, described by matrix-flow formulas known as the Darcy-Richards equations. Soil properties would also determine plant available moisture and thereby control transpiration. These models are data demanding, computationally intensive, parameter rich and founded on a wrong assumption. Instead, we argue it is not the soil that is in control of hydrology, it is the ecosystem. Our assumption is motivated by several arguments. Firstly, in well-developed soils the dominant flow mechanism is preferential, which is not particularly related to soil properties. Secondly, we observe that it is the ecosystem, rather than the soil, that determines the land-surface water balance and hydrological processes. Top-down analysis by large-sample datasets reveal that soil properties are often a poor predictor of hydrological signatures. Bottom-up hydrological models usually do not directly use field measurements of the soil, but "rebalance" the observed soil texture and translate it to soil structure by vegetation indices. Thus, soil-based models may be appropriate at small scale in non-vegetated and agricultural environments, but introduce unnecessary complexity and sub-optimal results in catchments with permanent vegetation. Progress in hydrology largely relies on abandoning the compartmentalized approach, putting ecosystem at the centre of hydrology. This paradigm shift is needed to build more realistic and simpler hydrological models for a changing environment, which is an essential issue in the Decade of Panta Rhei.
Language:
English
Type:
info:eu-repo/semantics/conferenceObject
Permalink