ALBERT

Description: Observations and models agree that the Greenland Ice Sheet (GrIS) surface mass balance (SMB) has decreased since the end of the 1990s due to an increase in meltwater runoff and that this trend will accelerate in the future. However, large uncertainties remain, partly due to different approaches for modelling the GrIS SMB, which have to weigh physical complexity or low computing time, different spatial and temporal resolutions, different forcing fields, and different ice sheet topographies and extents, which collectively make an inter-comparison difficult. Our GrIS SMB model intercomparison project (GrSMBMIP) aims to refine these uncertainties by intercomparing 13 models of four types which were forced with the same ERA-Interim reanalysis forcing fields, except for two global models. We interpolate all modelled SMB fields onto a common ice sheet mask at 1 km horizontal resolution for the period 1980–2012 and score the outputs against (1) SMB estimates from a combination of gravimetric remote sensing data from GRACE and measured ice discharge; (2) ice cores, snow pits and in situ SMB observations; and (3) remotely sensed bare ice extent from MODerate-resolution Imaging Spectroradiometer (MODIS). Spatially, the largest spread among models can be found around the margins of the ice sheet, highlighting model deficiencies in an accurate representation of the GrIS ablation zone extent and processes related to surface melt and runoff. Overall, polar regional climate models (RCMs) perform the best compared to observations, in particular for simulating precipitation patterns. However, other simpler and faster models have biases of the same order as RCMs compared with observations and therefore remain useful tools for long-term simulations or coupling with ice sheet models. Finally, it is interesting to note that the ensemble mean of the 13 models produces the best estimate of the present-day SMB relative to observations, suggesting that biases are not systematic among models and that this ensemble estimate can be used as a reference for current climate when carrying out future model developments. However, a higher density of in situ SMB observations is required, especially in the south-east accumulation zone, where the model spread can reach 2 m w.e. yr−1 due to large discrepancies in modelled snowfall accumulation.

Description: The impact of Arctic sea ice decline on the weather and climate in mid-latitudes is still much debated, with observation suggesting a strong and models a much weaker link. In this study, we use the atmospheric model OpenIFS, in a set of model experiments following the protocol outlined in the Polar Amplification Model Intercomparison Project (PAMIP), to investigate whether the simulated atmospheric response to future changes in Arctic sea ice fundamentally depends on model resolution. More specifically, we increase the horizontal resolution of the model from 125km to 39km with 91 vertical levels; in a second step resolution is further increased to 16km with 137 levels in the vertical. The model does produce a response to sea ice decline with a weaker mid latitude Atlantic jet and increased blocking in the high latitude Atlantic, but no sensitivity to resolution can be detected with 100 members. Furthermore we find that the ensemble convergence toward the mean is not impacted by the model resolutions considered here.

Description: The OpenIFS - FESOM2 coupled model is presented and first results of coupled climate simulations with the new model are shown. The model performs well for present day climate and is slightly too sensitive for reduced co2 in per-industrial settings. It shows similar long term sea surface biases as EC-Earth3, based on IFS&OpenIFS radiation biases. FESOM2 may be considered as alternative to NEMO for EC-Earth4, and OpenIFS as an alternative to ECHAM6 and ICON-A at AWI. Future work includes model tuneing, modifying resolutions and coupling of further Earth System Model components such as the dynamic land vegetation model LPJ-Guess. The model will be used within the ESM Project.

Description: The development of the third installment of the climate model EC-Earth is nearing its completion. The quality of EC-Earth simulations in the current state is analysed in comparison to a number of other climate models that are currently in use at the Alfred Wegener Institute’s Climate Sciences Department. By varying a set of greenhouse gases and orbital parameters, four scenarios of Present Day, Pre-Industrial, Last Interglacial and Mid-Holocene climate are designed. EC-Earth is set up and applied to simulate these climate scenarios. In conjunction with observational data, reanalysis data and proxy based climate reconstructions, these simulations are used to measure the quality of EC-Earth climate simulations. The variables examined for this purpose are land and sea surface temperature, air temperature, precipitation, and sea ice concentration. Furthermore, the ability of EC-Earth to reproduce global ocean currents and known climate patterns, such as the El Nino Southern Oscillation, is checked in order to gain insight into the variability of the simulated climate. EC-Earth is found to be in an advanced state of development with a rough setup process but mostly stable simulations. Both Present Day climate and paleoclimates are reproduced more accurately than in other climate models that are in use at Alfred Wegener Institute. Remaining issues to be solved are underestimated strength of important ocean currents and a high latitude warm bias in Present Day simulations.

Description: A new global climate model setup using FESOM2.0 for the sea ice‐ocean component and ECHAM6.3 for the atmosphere and land surface has been developed. Replacing FESOM1.4 by FESOM2.0 promises a higher efficiency of the new climate setup compared to its predecessor. The new setup allows for long‐term climate integrations using a locally eddy‐resolving ocean. Here it is evaluated in terms of (1) the mean state and long‐term drift under preindustrial climate conditions, (2) the fidelity in simulating the historical warming, and (3) differences between coarse and eddy‐resolving ocean configurations. The results show that the realism of the new climate setup is overall within the range of existing models. In terms of oceanic temperatures, the historical warming signal is of smaller amplitude than the model drift in case of a relatively short spin‐up. However, it is argued that the strategy of “de‐drifting” climate runs after the short spin‐up, proposed by the HighResMIP protocol, allows one to isolate the warming signal. Moreover, the eddy‐permitting/resolving ocean setup shows notable improvements regarding the simulation of oceanic surface temperatures, in particular in the Southern Ocean.

Description: Widespread mismatches between proxy-based and modelling studies of the Last Glacial Maximum (LGM) has limited better understanding about interglacial-glacial climate change. In this study, we incorporate non-breaking surface waves (NBW) induced mixing into an ocean model to assess the potential role of waves in changing a simulation of LGM upper oceans. Our results show a substantial 40 m subsurface warming introduced by surface waves in LGM summer, with larger magnitudes relative to the present-day ocean. At the ocean surface, according to the comparison between the proxy data and our simulations, the incorporation of the surface wave process into models can potentially decrease the model-data discrepancy for the LGM ocean. Therefore, our findings suggest that the inclusion of NBW is helpful in simulating glacial oceans.

Description: Understanding the dynamics of warm climate states has gained increasing importance in the face of anthropogenic climate change. During the Last Interglacial (LIG, ∼128 to 116 ka), greenhouse gas concentrations and high latitude insolation were higher than pre-industrial levels, causing a high-latitude warming (Turney and Jones, 2010; Pfeiffer and Lohmann, 2016). We present a suite of climate model results (COSMOS, MPI-ESM, AWI-CM, EC-Earth) to evaluate the patterns and compare the simulations with the above-mentioned surface temperature reconstructions, seasonal archives (Felis et al., 2015; Brocas et al., 2017), and sea ice reconstructions (Stein et al., 2017). As a result of this modestly warmer climate, polar ice sheets were smaller and estimates report that the global mean sea level was 6-9 meters higher than today (Dutton et al., 2015). The sensitivity of the Antarctic Ice sheet is related to the local temperature around the West Antarctic Ice Sheet (WAIS) (Sutter et al., 2016). Our ice sheet model experiments indicate that a 2-3°C local warming causes already a partially collapsed, irreversible WAIS. A pronounced subsurface oceanic warming can destabilize the WAIS, resulting in an oceanic gateway between the Ross and Weddell Seas. A sensitivity study using the new oceanic gateway between the Atlantic and Pacific Oceans as a bathymetrical boundary condition indicates that this region would be covered by sea ice. Mixing due to sea-ice formation prevents a pronounced warming around the WAIS and would stabilize the WAIS. Thus, the disintegration of the WAIS is probably related to non-local influences like in Hellmer et al. (2017) where the shelves of West Antarctica are warmed from below by Circumpolar Deep Water.

Description: Using the depth (z) and density (ϱ) frameworks, we analyze local contributions to AMOC variability in a 900-year simulation with the AWI climate model. Both frameworks reveal a consistent interdecadal variability; however, the correlation between their maxima deteriorates on year-to-year scales. We demonstrate the utility of analyzing the spatial patterns of sinking and diapycnal transformations through depth levels and isopycnals. The success of this analysis relies on the spatial binning of these maps which is especially crucial for the maps of vertical velocities which appear to be too noisy in the main regions of up- and downwelling because of stepwise bottom topography. Furthermore, we show that the AMOC responds to fast (annual or faster) fluctuations in atmospheric forcing associated with the NAO. This response is more obvious in the ϱ than in the z framework. In contrast, the link between AMOC deep water production south of Greenland is found for slower fluctuations and is consistent between the frameworks.

Description: Owing to the complicated spatial–temporal characteristics of East Asian precipitation (EAP), climate models have limited skills in simulating the modern Asian climate. This consequently leads to large uncertainties in simulations of the past EAP variation and future projections. Here, we explore the performance of the newly developed Alfred Wegener Institute Climate Model,version 3 (AWI-CM3) in simulating the climatological summer EAP. To test whether the model's skill depends on its atmosphere resolution, we design two AWI-CM3 simulations with different horizontal resolutions. The result shows that both simulations have acceptable performance in simulating the summer mean EAP, generally better than the majority of individual models participating in the Coupled Model Intercomparison Project (CMIP6). However, for the monthly EAP from June to August, AWI-CM3 exhibits a decayed skill, which is due to the subseasonal movement of the western Pacific subtropical high bias. The higher-resolution AWI-CM3 simulation shows an overall improvement relative to the one performed at a relatively lower resolution in all aspects taken into account regarding the EAP. We conclude that AWI-CM3 is a suitable tool for exploring the EAP for the observational period. Having verified the model's skill for modern climate, we suggest employing the AWI-CM3, especially with high atmosphere resolution, both for applications in paleoclimate studies and future projections.