ALBERT

Description: We explore thermal convection of a fluid with a temperature-dependent viscosity in a basally heated 3-D spherical shell using linear stability analyses and numerical experiments, while considering the application of our results to terrestrial planets. The inner to outer radius ratio of the shell f assumed in the linear stability analyses is in the range of 0.11–0.88. The critical Rayleigh number R c for the onset of thermal convection decreases by two orders of magnitude as f increases from 0.11 to 0.88, when the viscosity depends sensitively on the temperature, as is the case for real mantle materials. Numerical simulations carried out in the range of f  = 0.11–0.55 show that a thermal boundary layer (TBL) develops both along the surface and bottom boundaries to induce cold and hot plumes, respectively, when f is 0.33 or larger. However, for smaller f values, a TBL develops only on the bottom boundary. Convection occurs in the stagnant-lid regime where the root mean square velocity on the surface boundary is less than 1 per cent of its maximum at depth, when the ratio of the viscosity at the surface boundary to that at the bottom boundary exceeds a threshold that depends on f . The threshold decreases from 10 6.5 at f  = 0.11 to 10 4 at f  = 0.55. If the viscosity at the base of the convecting mantle is 10 20 –10 21  Pa s, the Rayleigh number exceeds R c for Mars, Venus and the Earth, but does not for the Moon and Mercury; convection is unlikely to occur in the latter planets unless the mantle viscosity is much lower than 10 20  Pa s and/or the mantle contains a strong internal heat source.

Description: A series of linear analysis was performed on the onset of thermal convection of highly compressible fluids, in order to deepen the fundamental insights into the mantle convection of massive super-Earths in the presence of strong adiabatic compression. We consider the temporal evolution (growth or decay) of an infinitesimal perturbation superimposed to a highly compressible fluid which is in a hydrostatic (motionless) and conductive state in a basally heated horizontal layer. As a model of pressure-dependence in material properties, we employed an exponential decrease in thermal expansivity α and exponential increase in (reference) density with depth. The linearized equations for conservation of mass, momentum and internal (thermal) energy are numerically solved for the critical Rayleigh number as well as the vertical profiles of eigenfunctions for infinitesimal perturbations. The above calculations are repeatedly carried out by systematically varying (i) the dissipation number (Di), (ii) the temperature at the top surface and (iii) the magnitude of pressure-dependence in α and . Our analysis demonstrated that the onset of thermal convection is strongly affected by the adiabatic compression, in response to the changes in the static stability of thermal stratification in the fluid layer. For sufficiently large Di where a thick sublayer of stable stratification develops in the layer, for example, the critical Rayleigh number explosively increases with Di, together with drastic decreases in the length scales of perturbations both in vertical and horizontal directions. In particular, for very large Di, a thick ‘stratosphere’ occurs in the fluid layer where the vertical motion is significantly suppressed, resulting in a shrink of the incipient convection in a thin sublayer of unstable thermal stratification. In addition, when Di exceeds a threshold value above which a thermal stratification becomes stable in the entire layer, no perturbation is allowed to grow with time regardless of the Rayleigh number and/or the horizontal wavelength. We also found that the effect of adiabatic compression becomes prominent for higher temperature at the top surface of the fluid layer. These findings may imply the crucial importance of adiabatic compression in understanding the dynamics and evolution of the mantles of massive super-Earths, particularly for those orbiting their parent stars very closely.