ALBERT

Notes: The influence of elevated [CO2] on the uptake and assimilation of nitrate and ammonium was investigated by growing tobacco plants in hydroponic culture with 2 mm nitrate or 1 mm ammonium nitrate and ambient or 800 p.p.m. [CO2]. Leaves and roots were harvested at several times during the diurnal cycle to investigate the levels of the transcripts for a high-affinity nitrate transporter (NRT2), nitrate reductase (NIA), cytosolic and plastidic glutamine synthetase (GLN1, GLN2), the activity of NIA and glutamine synthetase, the rate of 15N-nitrate and 15N-ammonium uptake, and the levels of nitrate, ammonium, amino acids, 2-oxoglutarate and carbohydrates. (i) In source leaves of plants growing on 2 mm nitrate in ambient [CO2], NIA transcript is high at the end of the night and NIA activity increases three-fold after illumination. The rate of nitrate reduction during the first part of the light period is two-fold higher than the rate of nitrate uptake and exceeds the rate of ammonium metabolism in the glutamate: oxoglutarate aminotransferase (GOGAT) pathway, resulting in a rapid decrease of nitrate and the accumulation of ammonium, glutamine and the photorespiratory intermediates glycine and serine. This imbalance is reversed later in the diurnal cycle. The level of the NIA transcript falls dramatically after illumination, and NIA activity and the rate of nitrate reduction decline during the second part of the light period and are low at night. NRT2 transcript increases during the day and remains high for the first part of the night and nitrate uptake remains high in the second part of the light period and decreases by only 30% at night. The nitrate absorbed at night is used to replenish the leaf nitrate pool. GLN2 transcript and glutamine synthetase activity rise to a maximum at the end of the day and decline only gradually after darkening, and ammonium and amino acids decrease during the night. (ii) In plants growing on ammonium nitrate, about 30% of the nitrogen is derived from ammonium. More ammonium accumulates in leaves during the day, and glutamine synthetase activity and glutamine levels remain high through the night. There is a corresponding 30% inhibition of nitrate uptake, a decrease of the absolute nitrate level, and a 15–30% decrease of NIA activity in the leaves and roots. The diurnal changes of leaf nitrate and the absolute level and diurnal changes of the NIA transcript are, however, similar to those in nitrate-grown plants. (iii) Plants growing on nitrate adjust to elevated [CO2] by a coordinate change in the diurnal regulation of NRT2 and NIA, which allows maximum rates of nitrate uptake and maximum NIA activity to be maintained for a larger part of the 24 h diurnal cycle. In contrast, tobacco growing on ammonium nitrate adjusts by selectively increasing the rate of ammonium uptake, and decreasing the expression of NRT2 and NIA and the rate of nitrate assimilation. In both conditions, the overall rate of inorganic nitrogen utilization is increased in elevated [CO2] due to higher rates of uptake and assimilation at the end of the day and during the night, and amino acids are maintained at levels that are comparable to or even higher than in ambient [CO2]. (iv) Comparison of the diurnal changes of transcripts, enzyme activities and metabolite pools across the four growth conditions reveals that these complex diurnal changes are due to transcriptional and post-transcriptional mechanisms, which act several steps and are triggered by various signals depending on the condition and organ. The results indicate that nitrate and ammonium uptake and root NIA activity may be regulated by the sugar supply, that ammonium uptake and assimilation inhibit nitrate uptake and root NIA activity, that the balance between the influx and utilization of nitrate plays a key role in the diurnal changes of the NIA transcript in leaves, that changes of glutamine do not play a key role in transcriptional regulation of NIA in leaves but instead inhibit NIA activity via uncharacterized post-transcriptional or post-translational mechanisms, and that high ammonium acts via uncharacterized post-transcriptional or post-translational mechanisms to stabilize glutamine synthetase activity during the night.

Notes: 
AGPase, ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase
GS, glutamine synthetase
GOGAT, glutamate : oxoglutarate amino transferase
NADP-ICDH, NADP-dependent isocitrate dehydrogenase
NR, nitrate reductase
OPPP, oxidative pentose phosphate pathway
3PGA, glycerate-3-phosphate
PEPCase, phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase
Rubisco, ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase
SPS, sucrose phosphate-synthase

This review first summarizes the numerous studies that have described the interaction between the nitrogen supply and the response of photosynthesis, metabolism and growth to elevated [CO2]. The initial stimulation of photosynthesis in elevated [CO2] is often followed by a decline of photosynthesis, that is typically accompanied by a decrease of ribulose-1,5-bisphosphate carboxylase/oxygenase (Rubisco), an accumulation of carbohydrate especially starch, and a decrease of the nitrogen concentration in the plant. These changes are particularly marked when the nitrogen supply is low, whereas when the nitrogen supply is adequate there is no acclimation of photosynthesis, no major decrease in the internal concentration of nitrogen or the levels of nitrogen metabolites, and growth is stimulated markedly. Second, emerging evidence is discussed that signals derived from nitrate and nitrogen metabolites such as glutamine act to regulate the expression of genes involved in nitrate and ammonium uptake and assimilation, organic acid synthesis and starch accumulation, to modulate the sugar-mediated repression of the expression of genes involved in photosynthesis, and to modulate whole plant events including shoot–root allocation, root architecture and flowering. Third, increased rates of growth in elevated [CO2] will require higher rates of inorganic nitrogen uptake and assimilation. Recent evidence is discussed that an increased supply of sugars can increase the rates of nitrate and ammonium uptake and assimilation, the synthesis of organic acid acceptors, and the synthesis of amino acids. Fourth, interpretation of experiments in elevated [CO2] requires that the nitrogen status of the plants is monitored. The suitability of different criteria to assess the plant nitrogen status is critically discussed. Finally the review returns to experiments with elevated [CO2] and discusses the following topics: is, and if so how, are nitrate and ammonium uptake and metabolism stimulated in elevated [CO2], and does the result depend on the nitrogen supply? Is acclimation of photosynthesis the result of sugar-mediated repression of gene expression, end-product feedback of photosynthesis, nitrogen-induced senescence, or ontogenetic drift? Is the accumulation of starch a passive response to increased carbohydrate formation, or is it triggered by changes in the nutrient status? How do changes in sugar production and inorganic nitrogen assimilation interact in different conditions and at different stages of the life history to determine the response of whole plant growth and allocation to elevated [CO2]?

Notes: Diurnal changes of transcript levels for key enzymes in nitrate and organic acid metabolism and the accompanying changes of enzyme activities and metabolite levels were investigated in nitrogen-sufficient wild-type tobacco, in transfomants with decreased expression of nitrate reductase, and in nitrate-deficient wild-type tobacco. (i) In nitrogen-sufficient wild-type plants, transcript levels for nitrate reductase (NR, EC 1.6.6.1), nitrite reductase (NIR, EC 1.7.7.1) and phosphoenolpyruvate carboxylase (PEPC, EC 4.1.1.31) were high at the end of the night and decreased markedly during the light period. The levels of these three transcripts were increased and the diurnal changes were damped in genotypes with decreased expression of nitrate reductase. The levels of these transcripts were very low in nitrate-limited wild-type plants, except for a small rise after irrigation with 0·2 mM nitrate. (ii) The levels of the transcripts for cytosolic pyruvate kinase (PK, EC 2.7.1.40), mitochondrial citrate synthase (CS, EC 4.1.3.7) and NADP-isocitrate dehydrogenase (NADP-ICDH, EC 1.1.1.42) were highest at the end of the light period and beginning of the night. These three transcripts increase and the diurnal changes were damped in genotypes with decreased expression of NR. (iii) The diurnal changes of transcript levels were accompanied by changes in the activities of the encoded enzymes. The activities of NR and PEPC were highest in the early part of the light period, whereas the activities of PK and NADP-ICDH were highest later in the light period and during the first part of the night and CS activity was highest at the end of the night. Activity of PEPC, PK, CS and NADP-ICDH increased and the diurnal changes were damped in genotypes with low expression of NR. Activity of all four enzymes decreased in nitrate-limited wild-type plants. (iv) In the light, malate accumulated, citrate decreased, and about 30% of the assimilated nitrate accumulated temporarily as glutamine, ammonium, glycine and serine. These changes were reversed during the night. (v) It is proposed that the diurnal changes of expression facilitate preferential synthesis of malate to act as a counter-anion for pH regulation during the first part of the light period when NR activity is high, and preferential synthesis of 2-oxoglutarate to act as a nitrogen acceptor later in the day when large amounts of nitrogen have accumulated in ammonium, glutamine and other amino acids including glycine in the photorespiration pathway, and NR activity has been decreased.

Notes: As reported in a previous paper (Plant, Cell and Environment 24, 357–365, 2001), introduction of sucrose phosphorylase into the cytosol of potato results in increased respiration, an inhibition of starch accumulation and decreased tuber yield. Herein a more detailed investigation into the effect of sucrose phosphorylase expression on tuber metabolism, in order to understand why storage and growth are impaired is described. (1) Although the activity of the introduced sucrose phosphorylase was low and accounted for less than 10% of that of sucrose synthase its expression led to a decrease in the activities of enzymes of starch synthesis relative to enzymes of glycolysis and relative to total amylolytic activity. (2) Incubation of tuber discs in [14C]glucose revealed that the transformants display a two-fold increase of the unidirectional rate of sucrose breakdown. However this was largely compensated by a large stimulation of sucrose re-synthesis and therefore the net rate of sucrose breakdown was not greatly affected. Despite this fact major shifts in tuber metabolism, including depletion of sucrose to very low levels, higher rates of glycolysis, and larger pools of amino acids were observed in these lines. (3) Expression of sucrose phosphorylase led to a decrease of the cellular ATP/ADP ratio and energy charge in intact growing tubers. It was estimated that at least 30% of the ATP formed during respiration is consumed as a result of the large acceleration of the cycle of sucrose breakdown and re-synthesis in the transformants. Although the absolute rate of starch synthesis in short-term labelling experiments with discs rose, starch synthesis fell relative to other fluxes including respiration, and the overall starch content of the tubers was lower than in wild-type tubers. (4) External supply of amino acids to replace sucrose as an osmoticum led to a feed-back inhibition of glycolysis, but did not restore allocation to starch. (5) However, an external supply of the non-metabolizable sucrose analogue palatinose – but not sucrose itself – stimulated flux to starch in the transformants. (6) The results indicate that the impaired performance of sucrose phosphorylase-expressing tubers is attributable to decreased levels of sucrose and increased energy consumption during sucrose futile cycling, and imply that sucrose degradation via sucrose synthase is important to maintain a relatively large sucrose pool and to minimize the ATP consumption required for normal metabolic function in the wild type.

Notes: The onset of sugar accumulation in cold-stored potato tubers coincides with an activation of sucrose phosphate synthase (SPS) and the appearance of a new form of amylase (Hill et al. 1996; Nielsen et al. 1997). To provide more evidence that these changes are involved in the regulation of cold-induced sugar accumulation we have compared the temperature dependence of sugar accumulation with the temperature dependence of changes in SPS and amylase activity. To do this, we investigated: sugars and metabolites; SPS activity, protein and transcript; invertase activity; and amylolytic activity and amylase forms, during the first 10 d after transferring tubers from room temperature to 3, 5, 7, 9 and 11 °C. After 10 d there was negligible accumulation of sugars at 11, 9 and 7 °C, and a large accumulation at 5 and 3 °C. Activation of SPS was assayed by comparing activity in an assay with limiting substrates and phosphate and an assay with saturating substrate concentrations. The activation state increased slightly at 7 °C, 3- to 4-fold at 5 °C and 5- to 6-fold at 3 °C. The cold-induced change in the kinetic properties of SPS was accompanied by the appearance of a new form of SPS with a slightly higher apparent molecular weight, and by an increase of the SPS transcript. The changes in SPS protein and transcript showed the same temperature dependence as the changes in the kinetic properties. Total starch hydrolysing enzyme activity was unaltered at 7°C, increased at 5°C and increased further (up to 7- to 8-fold) at 3 °C. The increase in amylolytic activity correlated with the appearance of a new amylase band on zymograms. Acid invertase activity showed a similar increase at 3, 5, and 7°C, and it did not correlate with the total sugar accumulation. The cold-induced accumulation of sugar can be reversed by transferring tubers back to warmer temperatures. We compared the decline of sugar levels with the changes of SPS, amylolytic activity and metabolites at various times (up to 14 d) after transfer of tubers from a 4 °C storage (for 14 d) back to 20°C. SPS activation state is reversed and the cold-induced form of SPS virtually disappears during the first 2–4 d at 20 °C. The cold-induced amylase activity also vanishes within 2–4 d.

Notes: Starch is of great importance both as a carbon storage reserve in plants and as a biotechnologically important product. The potato tuber is an attractive model system for the study of starch metabolism, because it is a relatively homogenous tissue in which conversion of sucrose to starch represents the dominant metabolic flux. All the major genes of the potato tuber sucrose to starch pathway have been cloned in recent years, allowing the generation of a suite of antisense transgenic lines to be produced in which the activity of each individual enzyme in the pathway is progressively decreased. Investigations of these plants have provided a complete picture of the distribution of control in this important pathway. Sucrose synthase, UGPase, hexokinase, cytosolic phosphoglucomutase, plastidial phosphoglucomutase, the amyloplastidial adenylate translocator, AGPase, starch synthase and starch branching enzyme have flux control coefficients (FCCs) of 0.10, approximating 0.00, approximating 0.00, 0.15, 0.23, 0.98, 0.35, 0.12 and approximating 0.00 for starch accumulation. These results show that the majority of the control on starch accumulation in potato tubers resides in the transfer of adenylate between the cytosol and the amyloplast, with a minor contribution being made by the first two steps of the plastidial starch synthesis pathway (the reactions catalysed by plastidial phosphoglucomutase and AGPase). This contrasts with leaves, in which the majority of the control has been found to reside in the reactions catalysed by plastidial phosphoglucomutase and AGPase. In leaves, ATP for starch synthesis is generated within the plastid via photophosphorylation. Several studies have attempted to increase the rate of starch synthesis by overexpressing pathway enzymes in tubers. The results of these studies and the role of other ATP producers in the starch synthetic process are reviewed. In the same time period methods of non-aqueous fractionation have been adapted to potato tuber tissue in order to ascertain subcellular metabolite levels. Results obtained from these studies allow the calculation of mass action ratios of the constitutive enzymes of the sucrose to starch transition. When taken together with the known regulatory properties of these enzymes the combination of broad control analysis studies and assessment of the mass action ratios of the respective enzymes allows a comprehensive description of this important metabolic network. Some illustrative examples of how this network responds to environmental change are presented. Finally implications of this whole pathway evaluation for more general studies of plant metabolic pathways and networks are discussed.

Notes: These experiments use Nia30(145), a tobacco nia1nia2 double null mutant transformed with a NIA2 construct, to define when sugar supply plays the dominating role in the regulation of nitrate reductase (NIA) expression. The null alleles of Nia30(145) are transcribed and translated to produce non-functional NIA transcript and NIA protein, providing an endogenous reporter system to track NIA expression at the transcript and protein level. The re-introduced NIA2 construct is expressed at low efficiency, providing a background in which the response to changes in sugar status is not complicated by simultaneous changes in the rate of nitrate assimilation and the levels of nitrate and glutamine. In an alternating light–dark regime, Nia30(145) contained high levels of nitrate and low levels of glutamine and other amino acids. This drives constitutive overexpression of NIA. After transfer of Nia30(145) to continuous darkness, nitrate remains high and glutamine low, but the NIA transcript level and NIA protein decreased significantly within 24 h and were undetectable from 48 h onwards. The decrease of the NIA transcript level was fully reversed and the decrease of NIA protein was partly reversed when leaves were detached from the pre-darkened plants and supplied with sucrose in the dark. The decrease was not reversed by nitrate or cytokinin. The NIA transcript disappeared when the leaf sugar content fell below 4 μmol hexose equivalents g−1 FW, and recovered when sugars rose above 8 μmol hexose equivalents g−1 FW. It is concluded that low sugar represses NIA, completely overriding signals derived from nitrate and nitrogen metabolism.

Notes: To assess how diurnal changes of nitrate reductase (NIA) expression in leaves interact with upstream and downstream processes during nitrate utilization, nitrate uptake, and nitrate and ammonium metabolism were investigated at several times during the diurnal cycle in wild-type tobacco. Plants were grown hydroponically on 2 mM nitrate to exclude possible complications due to changes in the external availability of nitrate, and to allow nitrate uptake to be measured in the growth conditions. (a) In leaves, the NIA transcript decreases during the day and recovers at night, and NIA activity increases three-fold during the first part and declines during the second part of the light period. Nitrate decreases during the day and recovers at night, ammonium, glutamine, glycine and serine increase during the day and decrease at night, and 2-oxoglutarate increases three-fold after illumination and decreases during the last part of the light period. The amplitudes of the diurnal changes are similar to or larger than in tobacco grown on high nitrate in sand. The transcript for plastid glutamine synthetase (GLN2) is low at the end of the night and increases during the day, and glutamine synthetase activity increases to a peak at the end of the day and decreases at night. (b) In the roots, transcript levels for the high affinity nitrate transporter (NRT2) increase in the day and decrease at night. Nitrate uptake is about 40% higher during the day than at night. (c) Comparison of the diurnal changes of the leaf metabolite pools with the rate of nitrate uptake allows diurnal changes in fluxes to be estimated. During the first part of the light, the rate of nitrate assimilation is about two-fold higher than the rate of nitrate uptake, and also exceeds the rate at which reduced nitrogen is metabolized in the GOGAT pathway. The resulting decrease of leaf nitrate and accumulation of nitrogen in intermediates of ammonium metabolism and photorespiration represent about 40 and 15%, respectively, of the total nitrate that enters the plant in 24 h. Later in the diurnal cycle as NIA expression and activity decline, this imbalance is reversed. NRT2 expression and nitrate uptake remain relatively high, and nitrate taken up during the night is used to replenish the leaf nitrate pool. Increased GLN2 expression in leaves during the second part of the light period allows continued assimilation of ammonium released during photorespiration and remobilization of the reduced nitrogen that accumulated earlier in the diurnal cycle.

Notes: Tobacco seedlings were grown in nutrient agar at a range of ammonium nitrate concentrations either without added sucrose, or with 100 mol m–3 sucrose. In the absence of added sucrose, nitrogen-limited plants had increased levels of glucose, fructose and sucrose, decreased chlorophyll, decreased protein, and decreased Rubisco activity, but the level of the transcript for the small subunit of Rubisco (RbcS) did not decrease compared with nitrogen-sufficient plants. When sucrose was added to nitrogen-sufficient seedlings, there was an increase of sucrose, glucose and fructose in the leaves, growth was increased, and the chlorophyll and protein content, Rubisco activity, and the RbcS transcript level did not change. When sucrose was added to nitrogen-limited seedlings, there was a further increase of sucrose, glucose and fructose, growth was not increased, and there was a further decrease of chlorophyll, protein and Rubisco activity, and a marked decrease of the RbcS transcript level. To check that the decrease of the RbcS transcript level was not an indirect effect due to changes of nitrogen metabolites after adding sugars, glucose was added to Chenopodium cells in the presence and absence of glutamine or azaserine. Changes of glutamine that suffice to increase and decrease the level of the transcript for nitrate reductase (Nia) do not affect the RbcS transcript concentration, and glucose addition still led to a decrease of the RbcS transcript level when the internal glutamine concentration was high. Tobacco seedlings were also grown in nutrient agar at a range of phosphate concentrations either without added sucrose, or with 100 mol m–3 sucrose. Phosphate-limited seedlings did not show a decrease of chlorophyll, protein, Rubisco activity, or the level of the RbcS transcript, compared with phosphate-sufficient seedlings. The addition of sucrose to phosphate-limited plants led to a similar increase of sugars to that seen after adding sucrose to nitrogen-limited seedlings, but did not alter chlorophyll, protein, Rubisco activity, or the level of the RbcS transcript. The addition of sucrose to phosphate-limited plants led to a slight increase of the level of the transcript for nitrate reductase (Nia), increased nitrate reductase activity, and a marked increase of the amino acid content. Phosphate limitation led to an increased level of the transcript for the regulatory subunit of ADP glucose pyrophosphorylase (AgpS2), and this response was strengthened when sucrose was added. The regulation of AgpS2 expression by phosphate and sucrose was further investigated by feeding sucrose and phosphate to detached source leaves via the transpiration stream. The level of the AgpS2 transcript decreased after feeding phosphate and increased after feeding sucrose, and the effect of sucrose was antagonised by phosphate. It is concluded that the response to sugar signalling is modulated by nitrogen and phosphate in a gene-specific manner. The significance of these results for understanding the visual phenotype of nitrogen- and phosphate-limited plants, and the response of photosynthesis and starch synthesis to the plant nutrient status is discussed.